| Reviews for The Brigata |
|---|
Kievsky 3/3/03 . chapter 1Having never read the Decameron, I've nothing to compare this too, and I got a little lost on the illness motif. Decameron is about the flight from the black plague, right? Here I can't really tell if the illness is actually a medical problem, like the plague, or more of a social problem; also, the setting has elements of past and present and so it's not quite clear exactly what time period this is. Thematically, though, nitpicking the setting doesn't matter. You have so many detailed, lush images here. It's beautiful. And the characters are described wonderfully with their mythic and personal characteristics. "Rose" is very pretty, and I love the astronomical elements that reappear throughout the collection. As for the "characters," I think Jason is my favorite, followed by Milton, then Lexi because I see many elements of myself reflected in her characterization. All of the people here are unique and have their own beliefs and motivations, and none are purely evil or perfect, which makes them realistic and their human counterparts probably very well portrayed. Your ending is wonderful because these people all deserve a happy ending. Overall the poem is very impressive, as you can probably tell from my happy rambling. Excellent job, once again. |
the Queen of Jupiter 3/1/03 . chapter 13That was mind-boggling and absolutely, positively gorgeous. I'm still reeling from it. I think I like "Rose" the best: it has beautiful imagery. I also love Death Fairy's poem in the review, hehe (just a note). It's wonderful how you brought all these people to full, breathing, living color in these poems. I'm putting this in my favorite stories, to take out and savor again for another time. |
E. Gao 2/28/03 . chapter 1And already I have been awestricken with your winter montage and the townspeople's plights, although at the outset they are identical. there are always defining qualities. Matt, matt is an apostle naming but not counting stars as the ten stroll through Puritan America and if I were there I would have certainly stopped and gasped the sight of ten beautiful ones (lead but not quite lead) by matt the translator. Rosa, watching the watchers of the sky and reading the scriptures as if the stars and sonnets and small red flowers were manifestations of the apostle's words. The skeptic grey-eyed daughter - for all she is tired of the Scripture - is still in love with the spring, a miracle so fateful that she disregards illness and faith; she becomes tired of the Scripture. John and his infamous eyelids lie glib tales of finery and fashions but does he really see the flames come nearer and nearer toward the pupils of his eyes? if he belives in himself certainly he cannot believe in God. Billy who walks with the women cares about more than the chemical makeup of the sun and covers miles with his thoughts regardless of his height which matters not at all. And perhaps age matters not at all either for Milton sees and smiles and is infinitely pleased and explains all he knows and dreams of infinity where the green matters more than age or height. Tierney flourishes in the freshest dawn despite the sickness and the seemingly directionless wandering of the ten. Her whistle made with the shortest of all men will most likely stop and question long afterward. David loves and is a lover. His flavored water is unnamed and yet he seems to appreciate everything - the scripture and the flowers and the people, the people most of all. Michael loves also, but loves a less universal phenomenon - only the splayed hand of another, the effects of a good coke and the pure joy of travel with the other (loved) eight. Here Jason is the one who counted the stars and is the real leader. He prefers unity of the ten it seems and is a catalyst of interpersonal gravity, and everything is golden when they reach the house and he can claim his myth-name. And so the ten have been named as angel-watchers and flower-observers and saint-wishers and readers and song-listeners and lovers and the convinced few. Not every Puritan was wearing black, in fact none of the ten except the night, the quietly lively night. EG |