Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: Developing
Simple Enigma 2004-02-21 . chapter 1
wow, its uber good. i really liked it, the last three lines are a bit weak, but it doesnt take away from the rest all that much. great subject!
Surautomatism 2003-12-21 . chapter 1
This was a good poem, I do like the way the war and photography stuff are combined in this poem.
Anastasia Morganne 2003-12-03 . chapter 1
I loved this! I studied photography in college, so it was not hard for me to envision this poem as I read it. Photographs still speak volumes long after their respective events have passed and you illustrated that fact beautifully here.
Seeker of the Way 2003-11-17 . chapter 1
Hi, I THINK this will be my first review of your work. You reviewed "pomegranate seeds". I will tel you I put it under "haiku" but it is actually a katauta:
Katauta
The Katauta is an unrhymed three-line poem with the following syllable
counts: 5/7/7. It is one half of a sedoka [doubled poem] (5/7/7,5/7/7). A
pair of katauta as a single poem may address the same subject from
differing perspectives.

Anyway ... your poem is alluring and has a wonderful poetic resonance. I like/no, LOVE how you combined two subject s BUT I DID NOT GET LOST! Beck does this in his songs sometimes, combining subjects.
Great flow. I just love the feel of this poem even though it is sad! I am going to try to add it to fave stories, but I think I am all full up there
;-(
SO, I am also going to add you to fave author. This one poem is good enough! Ususally I need at least three get a feel for the person.
Keep it 100 2003-11-15 . chapter 1
The two subjects do combine for quite a combination. You did excellent work on this piece.


~Heart of the Sword
Aidan Wolfe 2003-11-15 . chapter 1
A heartrending ballad ma'am
Thou art a woman of vision
Quite admirable, I salute thee
for unleashing another poets
melancholic, cheerless passion
Wasted Postage 2003-11-15 . chapter 1
I wouldn't change a thing! This was wonderful work! I absolutely loved it. It flowed beautifully. Splendid work!

~*~AbunaiChikara
Ps. Thank you so much for your review. It was very much appreciated.
lebuffle 2003-11-14 . chapter 1
Poignant. Definitely. Just at the end and beginning two verses ur structure of two rhyming lines per four-line phrase was a bit out when you added an extra line, but you might have done that for effect. If so, it was effective. Onle last point for improvement and I say this to loads of people but to me it's that important: don't try too hard to make a poem rhyme or to make the syllable pattern absolutely perfect. This poem is deep and meaningful, and that's far superior to the fact that it's got a well-structured syllable and rhyme pattern.

A very creative topic to write a poem on. I like that very much.
toxikon 2003-11-14 . chapter 1
Interesting poem, amazing how you combined the two topics! It works really well together, you've done a good job of it! I love photography too, so I could understand it really well :) Lovely poem!
Return to Top