Share/Save/Bookmark
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: The Mercurial Swords

random_reviewer
2005-05-09
ch 1, anon.
abuseWow! Wonderfully rich descriptions, beautiful imagery. Keep up the good work! It was really a surprise to me when his blade turned out broken, too. ^_^-KTH
SwordoftheKing
2005-03-21
ch 2,
abuseWoah... MAJOR plot twist, there. Your story is awsome! I would remind you to check and make sure that your subjects and verbs agree, and that your tenses (past/present/future) don't change around. Other than that it was great! Please update soon!
NanakiClaws
2005-01-06
ch 2, anon.
abuseI just read the Chapter one. But I like it very much! Good work!
Rizwan
2004-12-15
ch 2, anon.
abuseLooks like a good story.The descriptions could do a little bit more working on but overall i think it is great.Cant wait for the next chapter.
Conrath
2004-11-28
ch 2,
abuseAHH, please write more...
chrisu
2004-07-31
ch 1,
abusePersonally, it is veyr good. A sequel would be a good idea and the descriptions are very detailed. Good job!
Rating: 8/10
ladylore
2004-07-05
ch 1,
abuseBrilliant work!
AndrikTheUnsmiling
2004-05-30
ch 2,
abuseGreat story so far. Quiet a twist that Arrow recived a broken sword. Keep up the good work.
Lomiel
2004-05-25
ch 2,
abuseMagnificent.
I am regretfully ignorant of the titles, names, and much of the kind of culture you refer to, but this was still an amazing beginning. Honestly, despite having read the chapter title, I was shocked when the blade came out broken. As Arrow has already formed a bond with this sword, I hope that this is somehow resolved in future chapters.
Your descriptions are very poetic and rich, though I was confused a few times in your description of the elders (paragraph 17). I found very few punctuation or grammatical errors. Wonderful work.
Happy writing,
Shimoyo Lomiel
mike
2004-05-19
ch 2, anon.
abuseI'd sign in but i forgot my password anyway I really like this story and hope you write more sometime...i won't be able to read it for another 20 days but I'll be able to eventually
Elianor
2004-05-06
ch 1,
abuseIt's very nice... And it's the kind of story I've been ransacking bookshops for. Wuxia tales in English. Wondeful.
Anyway, I love the way you've incorporated words like 'Shifu' and 'Zhangmen', although perhaps, for those who don't read such wuxia novels, you might want to present a translation? Just a thought.
And just wondering, but is there a reason why the second chapter bears a striking resemblance to the first?
No offense meant, just a very curious reader.
Return to Top