 Matthew James Current 2007-04-09 . chapter 1Hm. Interesting piece you have here. You have some powerful devices, creative diction, and really good ideas in this. However, the fourth stanza seems to fall a little short.
The first stansa is excellent, the rhyme playing off some good ideas, the "warm façade" line ending the stanza with a powerful image that fits nicely into the poem as a whole.
It seems like you have a lot of potential in this work, and a lot of it shines through. A few small things seem to limit the piece as a whole. The fourth stanza seems to have diction with a plastic feel to it. The heart smashing into a thousand pieces, being glued together again, and the words "scar remover" in particular stood out as just not quite fitting.
Now by no means am I trying to insult your work here, you have some very nice ideas in this piece! My favorite lines from this piece were "Bought your words for 99 cents at the dollar store / Pasted them on your pre-made valentine / Because you knew I hated hallmark cards" These words seemed to have danced back from the edge of cliche and brought back something wonderful. They both impart a more profound meaning and do it in a way that is very clever.
So all in all, I'd have to say that what I see here is a mix of creativity and factors limiting that creativity.
My personal advice as a fellow artist would be to continue writing. Seek your own poetic voice, keep experimenting with styles and ways of writing poems. If there's one important lesson I've learned is that no matter where we are as artists, there's always more we can do, more we can draw out of ourselves.
You have potential, I would say, so keep on trying to bring that potential out. Remember to love the art! And enjoy yourself :)
I hope this was helpful ^_^ () |