 B. J. Winters 2009-02-03 . chapter 4There are a couple of typos here - the kind where words are missing a space (Iwhispered), (I.D.s andbusiness cards in it).
I would have liked to know more about the voice - maybe an impression, what Simone thinks he might look like - just a few words that add color or humor. Right now the interchange is very factual, and I think you have an opportunity to tease the reader that you've missed.
This is cute. I'll be back to read more. |
 B. J. Winters 2009-02-03 . chapter 3I liked this chapter much more than (2). I would actually suggest that you reorder - or blend them. I felt that (2) was repetitive, and (1) was so strong that it felt a bit like a dessert I didn't need.
This however sets scene, gives me some insight into "I", although I'd like more. Nice forshadowing. |
 B. J. Winters 2009-02-03 . chapter 1I generally don't like first person stories that start with "I" because it lacks grounding - I don't know where the character is, what they look like, or why they exist. However, in this case, I might revise that opinion. In a prologue sort of mode it works.
I loved the last line - give you just that amount of tension to add 2 plus 2 and get 4. Nice start. |
 Anne Davies 2007-12-08 . chapter 10 You *finally* updated! Now if only you'll do the same for "What Child Is This"... *hint hint* ;] |
 Coyote Phillips 2007-03-13 . chapter 9 grr...while this isn't exactly a cliffie, I still want to find out what happens...;) |
 shadowofreality 2006-06-28 . chapter 8I enjoy this story; you do a very good job at outlining the inner conflict and grief that the main character harbours. Keep it up! |
 a.small.town.bear 2006-01-31 . chapter 3Good chapter though maybe you should have placed this all in the first chapter like a prologue and then start the movie cause she's looking back on her life and stuff and then she gets to the plot. you know? but this is still pretty good! |
 a.small.town.bear 2006-01-31 . chapter 1Great chapter! pretty good beginning! |
 Karlina Ellison 2006-01-27 . chapter 7 Dwight? I had a bad feeling about him from the get-go... |
 Marged Hymffri 2006-01-14 . chapter 6So...are you updating anytime soon? Btw, this is *almost* as good as "Who's That Girl?"...:) |
 moscowsnow 2005-09-30 . chapter 6Certainly kept me reading. I like the slow build up of suspense, and there's some good backstory. Very convincing.
I look forward to reading the rest! |
 UnhappyPeople 2005-08-15 . chapter 6I really like how this is going, with plenty of character development and a slow build-up. A lot of great psychological thrillers have started out like that - slow and sombre.
If there's one constructive criticism I can offer, it's that you over-describe a bit. For instance, the sentence "Heartbroken and inconsolable, I cried for days" was somewhat jarring. Of course she's heartbroken and inconsolable; tell me something I can't figure out on my own! IMO, it would work better if you just broke up the paragraphs with a simple "I cried for days."
Anyway, this review's getting lengthy, but I really do see great potential in your story. Keep it up.
Oh, and Simone has *excellent* taste in films! |
 UnhappyPeople 2005-06-17 . chapter 4This seems really promising. Simone's narrative is perfectly realistic, and I love all the little references to Hitchcock. I just hope you'll get this story to turn out as suspenseful as his films! |
 reasonablysunny 2005-06-09 . chapter 4Oh dear. Something gives me the impression she's in more trouble now than she was before. |
 reasonablysunny 2005-06-07 . chapter 3Just thought I'd check out some of your other stuff too...
This is really cool, though you might want to pick up the pace when it comes to the action. The chapters are short--perhaps conglomerate these first three into one chapter of exposition before the action starts? I'm anxious to see what happens, because the character's voice is fantastic. Write more of this, please! |