Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: Meine Melodie - Reviews: Page 1 of 2
greenGalilee 2006-10-20 . chapter 1
The first stanza is absolutely lovely.

Good work.
e a t i n g . f l o w e r s 2006-05-26 . chapter 1
oh my, I loved the part "I fell in love with the season of today". lol in Utah we have every season every day! lol I also loved "we practiced swimming in the snow b/c the ice is s o beautiful from below". So cool and interesting. I enver thought about looking up in the snow..very very amazing!
poet tree 2006-05-01 . chapter 1
i was about to say, there's an author on this site with the name poetic abortion

then i saw your a.a.

"(i didn't fall in love with him) no, no i fell in love with the season of today"

i feel that line muchly

i am doing a sequel as soon as i fall out of love because i can't write violence when i'm happy

gor. geous. (your writing)
fairEtales 2006-04-11 . chapter 1
Oh wow. I absolutely love this. Gorgeous, beautiful work!
FunkyFlower17 2006-03-05 . chapter 1
i like the last coupla lines but 2-b-honest, i dont think this is ur best. beautiful nonetheless,

~mez~
poetic abortion 2006-03-04 . chapter 1
i love that first stanza. tre magnifique. (iamsocheesy)

"(I didn’t fall in love With him) No, no I fell in love with the season Of today." - lovely, lovely.



the ending...oh my god, i think i just chocked on my own laughter. itwashilarious&perfect.

~* noelle
Derek die Katze 2006-03-02 . chapter 1
I love the beginning. Reminds of walking by the pool, while the radio played christmas songs. Good use of parantheses. I think I spelt it right.
Jezsh 2006-03-02 . chapter 1
*applauds* Classy! The minimalist and subtle rhyme really accosted me, I love it! I would assume to get completely what this is about, but what I get, I really like. My favourite bit was the first stanza,

'we practise swimming in the snow because the ice is so beautiful from below'

Wow! What a line!
elasticbobaturtle 2006-03-01 . chapter 1
Great work; the rhythm and rhyme were nicely paced and matched.
sunday night sky 2006-02-28 . chapter 1
just love the first stanza... and the second. oh, and the third - i was gonna copy and paste, but it would have been the whole thing so... beautiful work! :D
crinkled aster ribbon 2006-02-26 . chapter 1
"(I didn’t fall in love/With him) No, no/I fell in love with the season/Of today./"

lovely, lovely.

"Sorry Noelle."

haha, that cracked me up.
lackluster 2006-02-26 . chapter 1
i fell in love with the first stanza. how could you not?

the whole thing feels important, to me. i have to figure this out

someday.
breezy nostrils 2006-02-26 . chapter 1
beautiful imagery. haha noticed the poetic abortion reference. great ideas! keep on going!
in theory 2006-02-26 . chapter 1
Beautiful, and the first stanza especially so. So curious about the reference to Poetic abortion.

And the last point is something I'm mulling over, it sounded like a plea almost. I've done it and recovered it and wonder now where I stand.

(loved the word philistine, not heard it since my church days. Keep up the great work)
none of burt's beeswax 2006-02-26 . chapter 1
Love the rhyming part in the first stanza. Really just added beauty to the wonderful imagery of swimming in the snow. I almost feel that instead of changed ("jackets changed for sweaters"), it should be exchanged. But I guess that probably means something specific. I love the idea of falling in love with the season and not with him. Sometimes I think that could also be possibly, then but I just remember that I'm to good at lying (to myself). Good work.
Return to Top