Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: The Tree
AkaraRhulain Ranger of Majicka 2007-03-21 . chapter 1
It's quite a good story, very descriptive. Unfourntanely, this is fiction press, and you said this was real...so?
gabriellafaith 2006-06-14 . chapter 1
Hm Interesting...story? Well, whatever it was, I liked it. I loved your imagry and creativity. Well done.-gabi
Jessica Wright 2006-06-14 . chapter 1
Interesting story. It's thoughtful and relfective. My only complaint was it went a little too quickly, and so got a little confusing.
Aelaris 2006-04-20 . chapter 1
Nice, thoughtful story. While it may be a true story, I do think that you did a good job with translating that into words, making it something more.

Nitpick: "...But I was also partially glad that the train moved. As it began, I picked up the complete form of a larger-than-life parasitic cockroach..."

Stuff like this, mostly, when you are inexact as to what the narrator is saying. Here, you don't link the train moving to the cockroach, which leaves it strange.(and you say 'picked up' rather than 'picked out' - I'm assuming the narrator didn't grab the thing.)

Asside from stuff like that, it was good, overall. You have an aptitude for pondering description, something that I like(I'm very literal, myself).

Also, fictionpress is for fiction, not your life. However, as I mentioned earlier, this story is more than what happened to you.

Kudos on it all.
pseudonym-of-mine 2006-04-12 . chapter 1
I like this story-rather haunting. Good job.
Return to Top