|Reviews for Fragrant Magnolias|
| soccergrL 7/30/07 . chapter 22
that was so good... yet so sad. at least it's an update. this fic feels so real. nothing is rushed, and the things happening really take time. it's also good that it's being told from the first person pov so we don't know what's going on in everyone else's mind. what happened to michelle? i really liked her. but it's your story. i hope you update sooner. keep up the awesome work!
| vfx 7/30/07 . chapter 22
I think it's cool Victoria's getting a job. She definitely needs something to do since she's getting rid of Melanie. It's so sad that she's acting that way towards Melanie, but she kind of deserves it. Though I wish they would get back together soon.
| rage of aquarius 7/30/07 . chapter 1
This is lovely. Just bursting with drama and all sorts of high school rich girl froufrou. I've followed it for a while now, and getting the update notification e-mail always brightens my day (or night). Please continue!
| TemptationWaits 7/30/07 . chapter 22
First of... for a not-quite-sober person, you did good with this chapter, the _only_ error that caught my eyes was minimal: "There was I time when I did those things without thinking twice" (I think the first I a so it isn't any big deal)
Now for the review. Victoria had some ups and downs. The "I'll get a job" thing is great, but the fact she's doing that for the sake of having an in-your-face-thing to throw at Melanie isn't the wisest motivation. Just like starting to eat, trying to change for the sake of someone else will do no good for her. I think it was my shrink that said years ago: “You have to change for yourself, not for everyone else around you. Then that will be a good change.”
And Scarlett knows that, of course. Victoria should listen to her and stop hiding behind her friend (or hiding at all).
Yeah, I know, being able to mess things up and do bad calls is what makes us humans. This is one of the things that make me like Fragrant Magnolias this much (besides the fact that there's a flower in that title)... Still, I have to cheer for a happy ending or something. Victoria and Melanie - despite of all the cheating and bitching and saying mean things and hoping that ignoring is going to heal everything - have great chemistry, something that Mel/Tracie Victoria/Michelle (and SPECIALLY) Victoria/Dylan lack.
Is it really just me to laugh when Tracie gets all pissed at Dylan for cheating when she’s all over Melanie? lol wtf is wrong with her? Actually, wtf is wrong with Melanie to ask for a break? Someone should bitchslap a lot of those guys...
Great chapter as always, it was worth the waiting.
| worstwriteronfic 7/30/07 . chapter 21
When are you gonna update?
| TheKatsPajamas 7/23/07 . chapter 21
Wow...Melanie is a bitch and Tracie...hmm, whore. So Michelle and Victoria, huh? Awesome, update soon.\chek it,JRG
| shellbell10 7/8/07 . chapter 21
All i can say is wow... i no other words to said
| XxKrazi3xLov3xX 7/4/07 . chapter 21
What! Melanie cheated on Victoria! and now Victoria's gonna do sumting she'll regret! Dont do it! Gah! sad and depressing chapter ( Plz update son _;
| Lonesome Bird 7/4/07 . chapter 21
Wow. I just read this entire thing at once.
To start, this story is AMAZING. Not only is it well written, but also realistic(especially the way the character's emotions are protrayed) and well thought out. Just...wow. I really like it, and the only thing I regret is reading it all at once. Because now I have to wait for updates. D:
But seriously, good job and I can't wait to see what happens next.
| vfx 7/4/07 . chapter 12
you have written an amazing story. update soon.
| Dropping By 7/3/07 . chapter 21
*shakes head in sadness* Commitment-phobes, the lot of them. Hello! I've been reading your story for a while, but never commented cuz I feel a bit silly without a login and whatnot. I must say it's quite good! Kudos. It has certainly taken a twist. I really hope that that's not the end of those two - it took them so long to admit anything to each other. Why do people like to ruin good things? Or maybe it wasn't a good thing...ah well. Keep up the good work! Hope you update soon!
| Natsume 6/30/07 . chapter 21
Hmm, another interesting turn of event. But I don't know. After reading, I couldn't say I liked this chapter. Its not that you wrote it badly, its just that..GAH! I hate to see them like this. ;_; I mean, them, breaking up so soon was totally unexpected. D: And what happened to Melanie? ;_; I don't to see her like that ever again. *sniff* Please update soon. ;_;
| ICaughtFire 6/29/07 . chapter 21
I quite enjoyed this chapter. I love where you're taking this, to a whole new level of drama. Although I think my new favorite character is Scarlett's brother. He is hilarious. Makes me wonder what would happen if I tried to microwave a CD...
| MBaxter 6/28/07 . chapter 21
Wow, this has taken a very interesting turn. Keep up the good work.
| soccergaL 6/28/07 . chapter 21
I like how you wrote this chapter. It seems so real. Like something that could happen in real life. And there are all these psychological defense mechanisms popping out everywhere. I can definitely relate. You're not only entertaining me, but also helping me study for my exam. haha. I hope you get to update this story more often.