Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: The Nineteenth Challenge - Reviews: Page 1 of 4

QueenOH
2007-07-30
ch 3,
abuseI know I’m like a year late reading this, but I just had to comment on this story Ode to the Moon Gods. This is my favorite one of this month’s entries.
you'll see
2006-12-02
ch 6,
abuseLol! I love the sword cane. Kris is a very amusing character.
Fenrir
2006-12-01
ch 1, anon.
abuse... Sorry I'm late; I kinda... crashed when I got home last night. But hopefully, the votes haven't been tallied yet...

Mechanics: Krys Night
Originality: Naida
Best: BlackCat
Stardust
2006-11-30
ch 1, anon.
abuseMechanics: Musashi, Originality: BlackCat, Best: Chiomi
Stardust
2006-11-30
ch 5, anon.
abuseAhh! That was good. Can you have someone e-mail me the TSC scenes?

I loved it...a lot...
Stardust
2006-11-30
ch 2, anon.
abuseAs always, spelling/grammar check is always useful.

Other than that, the flow is a bit weird in some parts, and the part where she goes to read the book in the library to hide from her teacher is rather choppily put together (Is choppily even a word? I honestly don't know.) But I do like the overall plot of it, and the idea of her lucky poker chip necklace. I'd like to see it expanded. I think it would be pretty good.
Akemi-san
2006-11-30
ch 8,
abuseBest-- Blackcat...Mechanics--Musashi...Originality--Kate McMillan
Raven Kay
2006-11-30
ch 1,
abuseMusashi- best.
Mushashi- originality.
Krys Night- Mechanics.
Motoko
2006-11-30
ch 4, anon.
abuseOriginality: Kate Mcmillan
Mechanics:Musashi
Best:Black Cat
ylaenek
2006-11-30
ch 8, anon.
abuseMechanics: Musashi
Originality: Kate McMillan
Best: Blackcat
Stormie
2006-11-30
ch 6, anon.
abuseHey, general review from a harrased Stormie... Who is only a few thousand words down for NANO! I WILL MAKE IT! And I'm on costume running crew,and doing a bake sale for Amnesty... Yup.

So. Nadia: If you hadn't told me, I never would have known english was not your first language. Your story was really good, and my only real recommendation is to do time as english time (16:30 becomes 4:30). My family functions on european time, so I enjoy seeing someone else use it, but other people might be a bit confused. Where do you live, by the way?

Votes:

Mechanics: Nadia

Originality: Chiomi

Best: Blackcat
Saiya-jinKISS
2006-11-29
ch 1, anon.
abuseMechanics: Musashi
Originality: Jade
Best: Kate
Monev11235
2006-11-29
ch 3,
abuseOriginality: Musashi
Mechanics: Kate
Best: Musashi
eowyn greye
2006-11-29
ch 1, anon.
abusechiomi - mechanics
musashi - originality
black cat- best

sorry for being a veg. lately. university is eating my soul. I'll try to write something for december. nice work everyone.
Jane Ellecot
2006-11-28
ch 1,
abuseAwesome job, everyone, but I can only vote for three. Sorry.

Mechnics- Kate McMillan
Originality- Jade
Best- Musashi
~Jane
Return to Top