Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: The Nayslayre's Infamous Carnival - Reviews: Page 1 of 4
Malulie 2009-11-06 . chapter 13
Honestly, I wanted David to die since he started the suicides.
But not in the way you ended it.
But in the way of police finding him.
*shrug*
Pretty fucked up story.
Nothing funny about it though.
More of angst, drama, fuckeduptiness, and tragedy.
That 2009-10-07 . chapter 1
Was so fucked up. Ick. But...I'll keep reading anyways.
Ziusura 2009-07-26 . chapter 13
I'm speechless. That was pretty flippin' amazing. I was certain David was going to kill himself on the show, but that ending was a pleasant surprise. It was all too fitting for him.

At first I was a little skeptical with the 'show,' especially since Andrew's two little girls were watching it. What parent in their right mind would let their children watch someone commit suicide? [although they stopped after Peter of course] Andrew was that desperate to hold on to David I guess.

While reading this dark tale, I kept thinking of a manga I read when I was definitely too young to be reading it. Tokyo Akazukin is an insanely twisted story, much like this one.

I really enjoyed reading this, and I thought I almost died a little inside when my mom kicked me off the computer about 3 screen scrolls down from the end of this chapter. Great job.
Crimsonoaks 2009-06-24 . chapter 3
this is so amazingly fucked up that i think i'm in love. i usually don't review till the end if there are a bunch of chapters, but i just had to tell you that this is gorgeously fucked up.
emmyisme 2009-06-23 . chapter 13
Slightly disturbing... well written though
HurtMe 2009-03-07 . chapter 13
Absolutely stunning. The perfect blend of horrific cruelty and undeniable insanity. David is a character you're forced to identify with, even though you don't want to. The ending is so well written I could barely comprehend what I was reading in my desperation to get to the end. Excellent job with this piece.
etheris 2009-01-29 . chapter 13
i don't know whether i should be disturbed by this or not, but i definitely know that it was awesome. seriously this was a great idea for a storyline, pulled off to absolute perfection. the writing seemed a bit off in a couple of places but was mainly amazing and the characters were very vivid and messed up. great work :)
CaseyBear 2008-11-06 . chapter 13
Throughout reading this I continued to question why I was reading this.

It is sick.

Totally amazing though.
Flawless-Beauti 2008-09-11 . chapter 13
I...wow. I'm beyond speechless.

I love this. I feel sick and horrible for doing so but I love it. I don't think I've ever felt...whatever this emotion is before. Any story that makes me forget to breathe because I'm so into it is a sure winner for me, and this was one that went above and beyond that.

I can't even imagine a better ending to this twisted tale. It seemed abrupt and confusing and perfect. I seem all over the place with this review I know but...damn.

It's amazing.
EllYouSeeWhy 2008-08-17 . chapter 13
wow that was, urm, morbid? very original if it was a film it I would definately get the directors cut.

Depressingly good though i'm not normally one for sad endings. :]
Roriam 2008-06-27 . chapter 13
Uhm... Not really sure what made me keep reading this... Curiosity? Masochism?

What ever it was, I don't know wether to curse it or thank it!

This was ... strange. Disturbing. Sometimes I felt sick and sometimes I laughed and at some points I realised that I was going to have a nightmare of this :D

Brilliant... Odd... definately original! I loved it... I think I did! It has left a few scars... and I feel disturbed, but I loved it!
The Ouch 2008-03-23 . chapter 13
oww my soul.
you are amazing.
Catseye*Rose 2008-03-17 . chapter 13
I loved this story. It was very dark and slightly twisted, and the writing was great. I liked the characters and their personalities, especially David and his interactions with the ghosts. The ending worked perfectly to tie everything together. I really enjoyed this!
Homophobes.WhoNeedsThem 2008-01-11 . chapter 13
... Woah.

Just...

Woah. I'm speechless. This is... Amazing. The best piece here, without a doubt.

I'm speechless. Blown away.

But damn, you have some fearsome talent. You should get this published for real, no joke.

Woah xD...
Back of Beyond 2008-01-10 . chapter 13
Damn, this is an amazing story! I'm so gutted I've finished reading it. :[ You should seriously get it published or something.

Lol, I was just thinking as I finished reading the end - which was brilliant, by the way xD - I had an idea that you could have wrote an extract from the website before 'The End', like - 'Due to unfortunate circumstances, Nayslayre's Carnival is no more.' You know, a bit like a tiny epilogue. xD Anyway, yeah, just thought I'd share my thought with someone, might as well be the author. :P

So, once again, great story! Definitely going on my favourite's.
Return to Top