Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: Roses are Red
no.peace.los.angeles 2007-01-23 . chapter 1
Cute. I like Eve's character a lot - she's the kind of girl to leave a guy a poem telling him that he's hot and comparing him to tobasco sauce (which is by far one of the best "roses are red" poems I've seen, truthfully). That says a lot about her. The brother is maybe a little overdone - unless you're trying to make him out to be OCD or something, I'd tone that down a little, maybe leave the "5 centimeters" bit out. Looks interesting so far. Can't wait to meet her love interest. Keep writing! :)
felicia13 2007-01-17 . chapter 2
Hee. I'm loving the journal. It rocks hardcore already. And I don't even know that much about this story yet. (You'll re-send the chapters to me, right?)

Maybe more detail would be nice. Because ... yeah. It's a little sketchy. Well, very sketchy. I don't like that so much. Just a little more would make it ok. And then I'd be incredibly happy! Yay!

p.s. Sorry it took so long for me to review this ... I don't know where my head is sometimes.

Felicia.
DevilzAdvokit 2007-01-14 . chapter 2
Excellent. Right off the bat you learn so much about the character and the storyline without taking away from the intellect of the piece. Her age and personality has been well-captured without inconsistencies. I'm interested in seeing more.
Sakura Taking 2007-01-07 . chapter 2
Very nice intro entry in the diary. I enjoyed the sarcasm you had going on oh-so-subtly. Many good things about this...like the fact that it is properly formatted, that always makes a good read.

Haha...more anonymous love notes in lockers!Yay! Lol. I must say, the plot seems very familiar, with the secrecy, lurking around "his" locker to figure out the combo, and such. I am pretty sure you know what I am talking about. Although, I am quite positive that this has not much relevance to that, but correct me if I am wrong. I am curious about that =P.

The dad's character seems interesting. Looking forward to finding out what the friends' characters are like, if you will introduce them, that is.

Hm...oh...nice touch with James Bond, post-its, and Timmy's- they make everything all the more realistic, or maybe I should say that they make a good "cherry-on-top". They're very...well...you =)...and I like that.

This chapter is fantastic and I love the realism of it! Keep up the fabulous work, as I hope and look forward to read more!
Sakura Taking 2006-12-21 . chapter 1
I was so sure I reviewed this...well, I apologize for the delay.

On to the review...

This sounds interesting. I hope you will be continuing this. Fantastic intro...you've got me hooked =P. I like the poem too!

Eve using post-its for her writing...that sounds a lot like you. I know many people do it (including me ). I think I am going to get a laugh out of the brother's perfectionist personality.

Like I said, this is a great start, and I hope that you shall continue on this. Hoping to read more...=)
Silently Yours 2006-12-18 . chapter 1
I know a good deal about what this is saying. It is good and if you do not mind I would like to use the poem, and send it to my girlfriend.
CHIIJOY 2006-12-17 . chapter 1
O like the starting. Post it note love. Sweet.
felicia13 2006-12-17 . chapter 1
Ha ha ... perfectionist brother ... that'd be me. No lie. I hate it when people touch my stuff. Rawr.

So ... I like it. Are you going to continue it? Please say yes. And don't let it die a bit like Glamorous did. Because I liked that one, too. And ... yeah.

Great intro and cool characters. Who's the guy? Want to tell me? Please? I can keep a secret ... and I like knowing things ahead of time because it actually makes the story better for me. I know when it's coming and I can see all the buildup without having to read it more than once. Please, Katherine?

Well, whatever you decide, it's a lovely start. Write on!

Felicia.
Return to Top