Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: Challenge Twenty Three - Reviews: Page 1 of 4

Amaranthine
2007-04-30
ch 2, anon.
abuseBest written: All in the Family-Dark
Most creative: Chilling Winds-Musashi
Best overall: This was a hard decision, but in the end, I chose 'Soulless Reunion' by henred5.

*my first review, and taking place around finals time. My others will be much lengthy-er, I assure you.
Myriadragon
2007-04-30
ch 1,
abuseHmm...

M--PandaKnight
O--Henred5
B--Meilan Firaga
Myriadragon
2007-04-30
ch 11,
abuseIt's just...clumsy. The sentence structures, paragraph structures, scene structures...it's clumsy.
Myriadragon
2007-04-30
ch 9,
abuseYagh! What is it with y'all and the creep factor this month??
Myriadragon
2007-04-30
ch 8,
abuseEm...okay...
Myriadragon
2007-04-30
ch 6,
abuseEm...I think you had a point here, but I kinda missed it. Try to find a better way to communicate it.
Myriadragon
2007-04-30
ch 5,
abuseI find myself highly amused by his view of sex :)
Myriadragon
2007-04-30
ch 4,
abuseHm...could be interesting. A few punctuation mistakes, and I have minor issues with you word choice, especially at the beginning (it reads about as well as Tolkien...when it comes to big or unusual words, use sparingly. Especially at the beginning, or you're likely to lose your audience before you've even begun).
Myriadragon
2007-04-30
ch 3,
abuseYah! Creepycreepycreepy! But very good.
Myriadragon
2007-04-30
ch 2,
abuse-sigh- the continuing vampire drama...not a whole lot to say, really.
Chiomi
2007-04-29
ch 1,
abuseOriginality: Pandaknight
Mechanics: Henred
Best: Meilan Firaga
henred5
2007-04-28
ch 1,
abuse-Mechanics: Arachne by Meilan Firaga
-Originality: Chilling Winds by Musashi
-Best: I'm broke, you're broke, let's leave it at that by Jadalycya

Well there are my votes, nice batch of stories this month. *nods head*

~henred5~
henred5
2007-04-28
ch 11,
abusePretty strange...had to read it a few times to get the jist. I think the plot line is pretty good, maybe needs working on but other then that brilliant.
henred5
2007-04-28
ch 10,
abuseThank the writer for adding another part to the short story.
Loved it, a bit strange and twisted plot line, but it makes it better. :XD
henred5
2007-04-28
ch 9,
abuseo_0
*blushes*
Return to Top