Share/Save/Bookmark
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: lullaby

Adenil
2008-03-17
ch 1,
M, you must have stepped out of your comfort zone with this one. I can tell you had a dab of trouble writing it
This line though: Waiting for the waiting to cease.
Great, very repetative and nicely constructed. I like it very much, thank you for writing it.
gnomesbeatfaeries
2007-07-02
ch 1,
Even though it should sound bitter, the fact that this poem is about a lullaby softens the hard, cynical edges to the point that you really have to pay attention to see that...wait, the persona is mad? Very, very good.
michelle
Gerard and Edward
2007-06-25
ch 1,
Some of those lines are amazing!
Nemonus
2007-05-03
ch 1,
(For good poetry I suggest Emily Dickinson and Mary Oliver: they're my favorites.)

Not bad. The rhythm falters, but around the end it comes together. I'd like to see a definite beat to this, almost so that it could be sung, because a lullaby about a lost lullaby is just cool...

You have some good phrases: "My heart dancing/An ugly dance indeed,", "Waiting for the waiting to cease.". "An angel humming" sounded a little awkward, as did some others. Again, a definitive rhthm is necessary.
Midnight In Eden
2007-04-18
ch 1,
Oh dear lullaby, come back to me.
Sweet sweet lullaby
put my heart to sleep.(eh, heart, cliched)
Coming from heaven,
An angel humming
My heart dancing,
An ugly dance indeed.
Never danced before,
Never nights plead to sleep. (this doesn't make sense, should pop an "I've" before "never" and a "had" after never.)
So come sweet lullaby,
Put my heart to sleep. (try to describe another part of you to get to sleep)
Night's been so long
Waiting for the waiting to cease. (Not bad but the repetition is a touch grating. What about a different second verb?)
Oh sweet lullaby
God's whisper to my soul
What's the use?
The heart is deaf (Again, heart = cliched)
Once used to see
But a lullaby so sweet
Made the sight flee.
What's the use?
My sweet lullaby isn’t here
What's the use?
It knows not of me! (ellipsis instead? Draws out the ending and you don't get an odd upbeat feeling)

Okay. So I've added in some punctuation about the start and made a few comments. Overall, it's bland. That's your big problem, you're using cliched and tired imagery. Spice it up. Other than that, you've got a cohesive piece that works well.

.:midnight:.
Not.So.Little
2007-04-06
ch 1,
Hm...This is good! I like the rhythm and the parallelism in it. This is something that a person can read and remember.
Return to Top