Cute this was nice. I've been trying to work on a story myself about best friends, and this is sort of a bigger inspiration for me (haha, thanks for that :)
Uncharacteristically of me I really like this. I think you should give it a different title and maybe make their be less questions but otherwise it's really interesting. I actually remember feeling exactly like this - I was always the one that liked the guys that two years later would be uber popular and never remember that we used to be friends.