Reviews for The Silver Tower
tatiyonnah 9/20/12 . chapter 1
Okay, I haven't even finished reading the first chapter yet, but I have to say they I'm impressed. U had me at the first sentence my friend. That is some sexy descriptive writing, very creative and original and it sets the tone perfectly- I already know that this is gonna be some dark and heavy stuff.

This sort of superior writing is what ive been thirsting for.
InkWitch 7/30/12 . chapter 20
Humph. That was... not fulfilling. Very disappointing. That was a waste.
InkWitch 7/30/12 . chapter 19
This is boring now. I don't see the point anymore. There wasn't enough detail to make this story interesting.
InkWitch 7/30/12 . chapter 12
Oh my god. Saran's EVIL? :O
InkWitch 7/30/12 . chapter 10
Hm. I'm still mystified. But this is getting interesting..
InkWitch 7/30/12 . chapter 9
WHAT. IS. GOING. ON?

this is excruciating!
InkWitch 7/24/12 . chapter 7
Um what. NOW this is getting exciting...
InkWitch 7/22/12 . chapter 5
Was there a point to this chapter...?

Still. Oh my god, I am just falling in love with you more and more.
InkWitch 7/22/12 . chapter 4
I just realized this is spamming. I'm sorry.
Oh my god, I am just falling in love with you more and more.
InkWitch 7/22/12 . chapter 3
Oh my god, I am just falling in love with you more and more.
InkWitch 7/22/12 . chapter 2
HOW is it possible that this only has 60 reviews? This is preposterous. I hate it when the good writers don't get the attention they deserve.
Now I'm going to give a review for each and every chapter you have, even if I have nothing to say but "Oh my god, I am just falling in love with you more and more." Speaking of which...

Oh my god, I am just falling in love with you more and more.
InkWitch 7/22/12 . chapter 1
I think you are a brilliant writer. It's so satisfying to see that I HAVEN'T gone crazy and that good FictionPress authors DO exist. You are like a long draught of cold water in a desert during the harshest beats of summer. Yeah, THAT good.

I did find a lot of things that made me, well, pause in uncertainty. Not sure if this "...running her hands across the silver walls until her palms stained grey and stank of metal" was correct, because how can your palms stink of metal? And how does paint come off on your hands unless its like very cheap paint?
And I think you should add something to this line, "Knowing that this routine would soon drive her crazy..." like 'if it had not already' because you said Saran didn't remember how long she'd been a prisoner. If she grew up in the tower, that would make sense but it doesn't seem like she grew up there. So that would mean that she HAD gone slightly bonkers, not totally off the edge, but enough that desperation and loneliness was clouding her sanity. So adding that phrase would make it clearer, I think.
This "Saran set about with her plan of escape at once." also gave me pause. Sorry, but didn't you imply that she'd been in this tower for AGES? Then why the 'at once'? 'At once' after what? Is this at the beginnging of her captivity? I don't. Under. Stand.
My suggestion is to get a good beta-writer. Someone who can read over your story and help you edit it a bit.

Because, seriously, you are just brilliant as a writer. This one chapter shows how much effort and research went into it: the words, the prose you use! It's perfect and I LOVE how it sounds so real. I mean, your writing has a natural voice to it and at the same time sets the time and age of the story. It's beautiful, honestly musical to my (mind's) ears. But often, people can miss a lot of things in their own writing (speaking from experience here) so a beta-writer who writes like you would help immensely in getting rid of the nitpick details that you've missed.
The other thing that I absolutely adore is how brutal Saran's situation gets. I mean, it's so medieval days-ish, that it fits. Perfectly. She nourished herself on her own pee, for god's sakes, how much more 'Game of Thrones' can you get? And she's so stubborn, and resourceful... Saran's already earned my respect. I'm hoping she doesn't turn out to be a typical character.
I love that description at the beginning, of the tower: "The tower stabbed out of the ground like a giant's bony finger: a smooth, single-windowed construction that shifted in the inconstant light like a slender mirror twirling in the sun." It's so beautiful and descriptive in a few lines. I think I've only come across one other writer whose descriptions made me wriggle in delight, her name is Traquor. Her prose is just as brilliant as yours.

Lastly, but not least, I love thy ending.
Reading on!
fellintothemoon 7/16/12 . chapter 1
Hi there! This is Melissa from A Drop of Romeo. The Silver Tower has been featured on our site under the Supernatural/Fantasy category. Here's your review:

Melissa Thinks: Featured on Project Fiction and the La Campanella Awards, it's a no brainer that this story is good. The Silver Tower is a fairy tale at heart. A girl named Saran is trapped in a silver tower (much like Rapunzel) and when she get's out, she finds herself in a bit of trouble. There is great voice in this story which, to me, made it truly sound like a fairytale. The author writes with amazing word flow and detail, giving it the feel of an actual published story. Saran is a very dynamic character; you can see her changes, differences, and lessons learned at the end of the tale. The Silver Tower, in certain parts, was a mystery that unraveled as the story progressed and that‘s what really kept my attention throughout reading it. It's not very often that we see a well written fairy tale on FP, so to anyone who's looking, this one's for you.
Preposterous 2/3/12 . chapter 20
I read your story on Project Publish and fell in love with your beautiful, almost poetic style. Your descriptions are never too much and never lacking.

I like how this is a fairy tale type story without the cliche, superficial perfection of most fairy tales. I love how this is a story about braving the unknown.

I think Marcel, Saran, and Pieter are great characters. You rock.
BethanyWrites 6/24/11 . chapter 20
This is so great! I love it! It has a wonderful ending! You should really get it published. Or at least try. It's a lot better than some of the books out there.

Thank you for posting this story up here. I loved it! :)
71 | Page 1 2 3 4 .. Last Next »