Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: The Magical Correspondences of Elin and Isabel
Lynn Johnson 2007-08-18 . chapter 13
First of I just want to say that I love the idea of a letter story and I think that you two are executing it wonderfully! At first I was skeptical about how the story would unfold, but I like where it is going a lot.

One thing that I would like to see is some more background info on Elin and Isabel's parents and the magical order. It's kind of cool how we get to find out a little bit more about it as the letters are written, but I'm just so impatient and I want to find out more!

Also, I really like both your styles of writing. They compliment each other nicely.

Well, that's all I have to say. I can't really think of anything for you to improve on, just keep doing what you're doing. I'm a fan and I can't wait for more letters!!
fantasywriter22 2007-08-03 . chapter 3
Okay, more constructive critism...

First Paragraph,"It seems as if it as," The second as should be has.

Third Paragraph,"Along side of being my older sister, Sofia has also become a wonderful friend," I don't really know what this is suppose to say, but I think it's somewhere along the lines of, "Along beside me is my older sister, Sofia...," Maybe? If not, you may want to re-word it.

Ninth Paragraph, "and possibly even know which the salad fork is," I believe know is suppose to be knowing.

These are the only mistakes I found. The story is coming along nicely. I'm waiting to find out what happen nexts and hopefully a story unfolds.

ANyways, bye bye! :)
fantasywriter22 2007-08-03 . chapter 2
Hello there,
I use to write letter stories all the time, but they were never finished...

Anyways, I noticed one thing wrong and another one may be wrong, but I cannot tell...

"I know He means", He needs a lower case "h".

And the maybe one:

"Well, some (all) would argue the house is more of a beautiful old mansion, placed magnificent seclusion with its lake, woods, and meadows."

I just don't understand it. I know what you mean, but I think it needs to be re-worded.

So, that's all I found. Besides that it's off to a fabulous start considering it's mainly made up on the top of your head. I mean, so far, your friend's, Hannah's, head.

I always appreciate constructive critism, so I thought I'd give it to you. :) Hope you like it too. If there is anything you want to say, just reply to this. :)
Hannah C. Thaw 2007-06-04 . chapter 10
hmm I wanted to edit that letter a bit more, i wasn't sure if i wanted her a spy yet. oh well, ill make it work! You need to write the next letter
Hannah C. Thaw 2007-06-04 . chapter 2
The first letter is so short! It didn't seem that short in the email
Hannah C. Thaw 2007-06-04 . chapter 1
Yay! Our story!! Fun times!
Return to Top