 simpleplan13 2008-03-22 . chapter 1Review Game!
-Flow
...The flow was good. The line breaks are very well placed.
-Technical Aspects
...I couldn't figure out why you capitalized Resplendent because that just didn't make sense. Also the second line should have a period after it. Also from A sign of rebirth to forever will last is a runon sentence. Also the last four lines I might get rid of an and and make it into two sentences.
-Descriptions/images
...well it's kinda hard to describe a phoenix in different ways, but you did a pretty good job with the baby's breath line and dew from the grass. Those were both really great
-Word choice
...plumage resplendent was really great and the rest of them were pretty ordinary, but not in a bad way
-Enjoyment
...I liked it a lot. It was about the same thing, but not too repetitive and the descriptions kept my attention.
-Poetic Devices
...the rhyming pattern was all over the place in the beginning. It was A-A-A-B-C-C-B-B. I might work on that maybe make the third line rhyme with again... that should fix it. Also the told part did seem a bit forced to begin with.
-Subject
...The subject matter is a bit overused and because of that some of it was a bit cliched, but as I said you had some really great descriptions and that made it different and well done. |