Share/Save/Bookmark
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: Of Proud Spirits and Losses at Night - Reviews: Page 1 of 5

MZ PEACHESZZ
2008-03-30
ch 11,
abuseI dont understand how she could be with child if they haven't had sex...did I just gloss over that? I thought they just kissed!
siddika
2007-09-15
ch 1,
abuseAmazing job.
crazyfish666
2007-09-06
ch 29,
abuseI love it, very nice! I had been worried it would be too similar to Titanic (the movie) but it is not at all. A few typos still exist, at one point you say "the survivors of the Carpathia" and later you say "the Jane" and "the Hannah" but other than that I cannot fault it.
Georgiana
2007-08-30
ch 29,
abuseI think you ended it nicely, although it is a great comfort to know that there will be more..hehe:) Ah... They are just so perfect for each other...=) It was a really sweet ending, but I think they deserved that, after so much they had to go through...

Thanks for the shout out, and I must say, it has been so much fun reading so brilliant literature! Although I'm afraid my reviews haven't really been of much help, I hope the blabbering at least was a little encouraging...?
Anyway, I will definitely be back for the sequel, so toodles, for now=D
Georgiana;)
Georgiana
2007-08-30
ch 28,
abuseI think it was nice that you mentioned Lilianna's quick conclusion about William's death, and then gave her reasoning for it. It made the whole incident more believable:) I'm sorry there aren't 30 chapters, but I'm looking forward to the sequel:) So, onto the epilogue... I'm so sad it'll all be over soon...:( *sobs hysterically*
Brackynn
2007-08-30
ch 29,
abuseWell, all I can say is that I can't wait for the sequel! While this was a very sweet wrap-up, seeing Kayleigh and Lilianna as friends, her life with William one month on and the effects of the Titanic on their lives ... I want more! I've come quite attached to these characters, and so, must know more!

Fantastic job -- truly. Keep writing!
Brackynn
2007-08-30
ch 28,
abuseI must say, this is a nice resolution -- not as in that everything's turned out perfectly, because obviously, it hasn't, but I do like the sense of closure you've left us with -- although while keeping some questions open! (Will we find out what happens in regards to Kayleigh's life in America and Lilianna and William's baby in the epilogue? I hope so!)

I loved reading about all their different reactions to the Statue of Liberty as well; I thought that that was a really nice touch :) What I also found interesting about this chapter was seeing a little into Anne's perspective on her late husband. I sort of wish we'd seen a bit more of her throughout the story, as she looks like she had the potential to be a fairly interesting player in the whole dispute between William and his father and brothers.

But now -- brilliant job, and so I'm onto the epilogue! :D
InkIllusionist
2007-08-29
ch 29,
abuseNo problem! I loved reading an reviewing this story and hope to do more in the future! I am alos glad you accuried SO many readers in the process! :D We all love this story! WIlliam survived! The baby's coming! There's a sequel! what could be better!?! This was truly a great story. Congrats on it! :D
InkIllusionist
2007-08-29
ch 26,
abusei hope it is william! ee .. i must see! onto the next chap
InkIllusionist
2007-08-29
ch 25,
abuseoh so many questions! I hope Will lives! I think Richard might be gone -sob- Phillip is nice from what I've seen of him. I need to see more before I make a full opnion. I hope to see him more! The baby should be 'babies' as in twins lol. a boy and girl. my fantasy haha
InkIllusionist
2007-08-29
ch 24,
abuse-lets out breath- dear god you're good at writing suspense! I was on the edge of my seat for that one! :) Excellent! He's ALIVE! -cheers- I wonder what more is in store! Hmm... lol
InkIllusionist
2007-08-29
ch 22,
abuseoh! oh! OH! he's not going to die is he?!? he needs air! Oh i do hope he makes it out alive! I know I'm not very good with constructive critism like Brackynn (who is a gramatical and technical genius) but i'll enjoy the story and give u feedback as best i can!
InkIllusionist
2007-08-29
ch 21,
abuseoh dear i wonder they have to discuss! I know I know, I've been completely MIA in the last few months! Sorry! I see you've posted a sequel! I'll work my way though these chapters and be reading that ASAP! Wonderful writing as usual! Thank you a billion for that little shout-out on your profile, although it is an honor for me to read YOUR work! It is splendid. Enough blabbering on my part. Onto the next chapter!
IheartStewart20
2007-08-29
ch 29,
abuseI have finally read this thing and it was spectacular! I was immediately pulled into the world that the Titanic existed in. You did a great job with this and I can't wait for the sequel! Kudos chica!
Rosetta S Moon
2007-08-29
ch 29,
abuseThe story was great. Can't wait for the sequel. I really want to know if the baby is a boy or girl!
Return to Top