Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: The Heroin Addict's Girlfriend
Midnight In Eden 2007-12-19 . chapter 1
I have to say ... I don't know about the "real" aspect of this poem. I find that a lot of drug, alcohol, etc. poems are quite preachy and cliched because the poet hasn't experienced anything remotely like what they're writing about and no offense, but that comes through quite strongly here. It's very generic in that sense, there's not a lot of personality to this in terms of imagery, storyline and ending. It's sort of like the same old story. I don't know how you'd do an edit but I think condensing this, adding punctuation and being more specific would really help.

Midnight
Smoky Bear 2007-11-25 . chapter 1
very heartfelt. you've conveyed so much of the charcter's feeling that this seems very real. I'm so glad she left him in the end. great work.
half-sketched.staccatos 2007-09-20 . chapter 1
konban wa

There were two instances that threw me off because you rhymed the lines, but - since you didn't do that anywhere else - it sounded a bit out of place:

"I found you where I knew you would be / Laying on the floor of the nearest shooting gallery"

-And-

"Or will it be death walking through that door [...] I don't know who you are anymore"

Also a couple of spelling mistakes ("is" instead of "it" and "waling" instead of "walking"), but those are easy enough to fix. I tend not to dwell on those.

I loved the first parenthesis: "(Maybe it isn't you)" ... The parenthesis add to it this feeling of fruitless hope so to speak. Besides for the couple of comments that I mentioned, this poem was absolutely amazing.

Off to read some more of your poetry!

Zaijen
-Shan-

fruitless hope
Brian Ledgers 2007-09-20 . chapter 1
wow.
this is amazingly detailed and it is amazing, keep writing because ur definitly good at it.

Brian Ledger
(#13 on your list)
Ps. Please R&R Me
Return to Top