Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: The Prodigal Son
Vulpine Ninja 2009-10-21 . chapter 1
What I like about this story is that how it relates to religion and beliefs. I'm a believer myself, but some things need to be questioned, like what Ly did.

But the strange thing is, although Ly is said to be 15, he seem rather mature for his age. I kinda expected Ly to be a bit more playful and agressive. The ending is a little vague, but I'm glad Ly decided to come home with the Priest.
LeahDude 2009-04-09 . chapter 1
I love Ly so much :] I like the story and the ending is really good. The fact that he didn't give up his belief is more believable. I love the parts where Ly talks about how desire is not sinful and the part where he explains why he refuses to believe in God. I know that feeling. People say that without suffering there would be no compassion...but tell that to those who suffer. Finding faith is a difficult thing so I love how you've intergrated everything in this story well.
Caisele 2009-03-01 . chapter 1
I LOVE THIS!

You're a great writer, and brought up some really interesting arguments here. You should extend this and publish it. Seriously.
M. Jayne 2008-05-11 . chapter 1
Rather amazing. Your characterization is wonderful. You really tackled the issues here instead of skirting around them, which added a lot to the story. Great work.
Lily Llynn 2008-01-11 . chapter 1
Very well-written, same as your other story. I think some aspects of this story are a bit... fantastical, perhaps? Not realistic.

The ending and the beginning don't quite match. The beginning paragraph is dark, and a bit angry (the character seems angry at himself). Yet the ending is happy, joyful, exuberant. I don't understand how the introduction ties in with the rest of the story except to introduce the characters, in a way.

Again, amazing writing, and characters as well. I think complex, developed characters are a rare find on Fictionpress, and I'm glad you've done so (with both your stories). Despite the romance in this, I wouldn't really classify this story as romance, because I think it's more about a personal journey and gaining wisdom. *So thus, I don't think I'll add it to my c2.

However, these are just my thoughts. I thank you again for your suggestions - if you really want them to be in our c2, you could suggest it to the staff if you desired. Thank you again; I'm very glad there is some quality writing here on FP.
Faery goddyss 2007-08-28 . chapter 1
You know, finding a good well written story on fictionpress is like trying to find a needle thrown into the ocean. But with this story I do believe I've found that damn needle.

This...was so well written, so powerful, so detailed and completely believable. It sounds as if its based on a true story, it's so real...I feel as if i can touch it.

I admit that when I first read it I cringed at two things. The idea of having to read a story of religion and of a priest falling in love with such a young boy. Naturally the first thing I got past was the idea of the priest and Ly. :P But the religious aspect kept nagging me. Mostly because I agree whole heartedly with Ly, and its always hard to hear, and read about your beliefs possible being wrong, and you being "misguided".

I loved Ly's character, the Priests as well. I like their stark differences, but I also enjoyed seeing the similarities. Honestly I was VERY worried about the ending. I dont know what I thought would happen, but in the beginning it sounded like you were foreshadowing. I thought for sure Ly would be killed, or the Priest would be...well, whatever happens to priests when they're found out. But no, :) it was a soft happy ending, and for that I thank you! I do ADORE my happy endings!

This was an amazing story, one I wont easily forget. I hope you attempt a chaptered piece of fiction. And should you ever come out with a book, let me know, I'll buy it to support you! :)
Return to Top