|Reviews for Persuading the Nonbeliever|
| ElegantDisaster89 9/12/08 . chapter 9
AW! That ending was adorable to say the least! I love that Luke ended up being gay, it's always the womanizers who really love me ;) lol. GREAT story!
| ElegantDisaster89 9/12/08 . chapter 4
NO-O-O-O-O! I LIKE ANDY! DAMMIT! I had a feeling he wouldn't last very long though... :( still though :( *sniff sniff*
| waterlilies52 6/29/08 . chapter 1
Very fast-paced. I love it! Thanks for reviewing my story by the way, a review for a review.
| Written 3/3/08 . chapter 9
well, that was a nice ending!
I know you say you don't do excessive details, but some details might have helped the story out a little. You don't need to overdescribe everything, but something about the writing seemed a little choppy, and the plot was kind of... random? I know that's a little too vague.
I think if you'd given the characters more depth and didn't use a desu-ex-machina like you did, it might have been better. but the happy ending is nice too :)
what I mean is that like... everything was happy, then everything went insanely twisted (which is a good surprise!), but then you wrapped everything up really cleanly again (luke is redeemed, andy is still alive). it seems a little TOO happy?
but it is your plot, so it's totally up to you. don't be offended that I said all that!
other things you could work on would be like... character depth. you have a really interesting plot, and if you wrote it with more atmosphere, it could even be a real thriller.
overall though, you did a good job! read it start to finish.
| Written 3/3/08 . chapter 7
what started as a cute story has quickly veered off track :)
I think it would be even better if you made luke kinda creepy from the start, but not really so much that we could notice right away.
or maybe you did and I just didn't notice.
| Written 3/3/08 . chapter 5
there's so much drama in this story! it's not a bad thing, it's just different :)
| Written 3/3/08 . chapter 3
Hello again! I've noticed the grammar things, but you already talked about that in your profile... other than that, things are going good! your writing sometimes seems a little choppy, but this is an older story, so I'll have to check out something newer after this :)
| Written 3/3/08 . chapter 2
hmm. darren seems interesting.
| Written 3/3/08 . chapter 1
ooh, cute story! you've written so much that I have no idea where to start, but this looks fun :)
| Sydney 2/5/08 . chapter 9
maybe a B
what about brant?
did he stop being a secret alcoholic - did he get someone in his life too
whos features did Andrea get?
you got a couple of small spelling mistakes
there arnt that many
and some punctuation in the wrong place
thats about it
otherwise I loved this story
| Hoodwynk 1/13/08 . chapter 9
Nice details on the wedding. That could be a girl thing instead of a writer thing, though. Nice ending and you were creative with how you made it a cheerful one by curing Luke.
| Hoodwynk 1/13/08 . chapter 8
So cute. I liked how you had a gay guy in a good light. They take way too much persecution.
| Hoodwynk 1/13/08 . chapter 7
Good chapter- everything fit together fairly well. It didn't seem like you had to force it to fit the story.
| Hoodwynk 1/13/08 . chapter 6
You did a good job on the depths of Darren's charie.
| Hoodwynk 1/13/08 . chapter 5
I like how she was naively innocent, but not to the point of being stupid/clueless. (concerning Luke's charie)