Share/Save/Bookmark
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: Imperfect - Reviews: Page 1 of 2

Toasty
2008-07-10
ch 2, anon.
abuseIT ATE MY REVIEW OF THIS CHAPTER! T.T I wrote so much and it ate it! Gr...

Lemme see if I can somehow remedy this ridiculousness. -.-

Summarily:
Seth is awesome. I love how introverted and uptight he is. Clearly he needs to get laid. Total opportunity for Seth/Sean action, because, two words, Seth's obsessed. The contrast between Seth and Sean is awesome. Twins are just cool, and the stark division of traits you've set up is amazing. I really like the puppy analogy, because it shows how much Seth is manipulated by Sean and how he knows it but still tries to play like he's in control.

Hopefully any reviews after this one now make more sense. If fictionpress eats this again, I'll shoot it repeatedly and then drown it.

~ KoT ~
Toasty
2008-07-10
ch 4, anon.
abuseOMG! Yuki needs hugs! Poor thing. He's such a bitch, though. XD I love it! Teehee. Still needs hugs. Lots of hugs for Yuki. Adorable little psycho ^.^ and SEX-AY! ^.~

I liked how you reprised the puppy analogy. ^.^ Ish very clever, methinks, though I'm no expert. I think experts would agree ^.^ And if they didn't, I'm sure I could find a way to get rid of them. .> Drown them in a bathtub or something. Teehee.

Again, poor Yuki. Must read to see what happens next!

I'm off!

~ KoT ~
Toasty
2008-07-10
ch 3, anon.
abuseMe again. Too lazy to put my email. I'm guessing most people don't review every chapter, but too bad! It's your own damn fault for leaving me with something to say at the end of every, single one XP Okay, enough stalling.

Eep! You have ruined the twincest! XP For the moment, at least. Yuki's awesome, though. XD I love how nonchalant he is, teehee.(Very much like Seth... Just kidding xP I couldn't help myself) Anyway, Sean's cool. ^.^ Not the basket case I expected, which is refreshing, but there is still time .> And hidden issues are the best issues.

Well, I'll just stop ze review here and keep reading ^.^

~ KoT ~
Toasty
2008-07-10
ch 2, anon.
abuseHello, again! I have finished Chapter 2/1
Toasty
2008-07-10
ch 1, anon.
abuseHah! Found you, CT! *pokes you* I'm glad you allow anonymous reviews, teehee, otherwise I'd have to borrow a friend's account or something crazy like than and then explain who I was and blah blah blah and it would get boring and complicated. So, anyway, I guess I'm supposed to be saying something review-ish, so...

OMG! SO CUTE! Megumi ish teh adorablez! He needs a hug and a tutu. Teehee ^.^

Okay, now we put on our professional mask so we're actually useful. Hmm... Yeah, not gonna work XD There's nothing imperfect about it ^.~ Maybe I'll try a professional hat next time...

I'm really looking forward to seeing any of the pages when you get around to drawing accompanying illustrations, and I will bug you to make you draw them. Consider yourself warned. Anyway, I'll flounce off and read the next chapter now. Expect yet another review for Chapter 2! ...well, I guess it's technically Chapter 1 if this is the prologue... Stupid technicalities... nobody loves them. Anywayz, tootles!

~ KoT ~
b
2008-05-16
ch 10,
abusei keep mixing sean and seth up. i feel like sean is a more fitting name for a guy like seth, but maybe that's because i know a guy named sean who is nice but has a stick up his ass... XD

not my fave chapter (sean's voice is too haughty for my taste ;P and his description of his suicide attempt is kind of weirdly matter-of-fact and monotone), but since i read the synopsis (gah i know the ending now! x_x) i can see that the relationship between seth and our little megu is subtly developing, and quite nicely at that. but why did sean kiss megumi anyway? argh weirdo!

i've been wondering: your descriptions of japan are totally on the mark, so i'm guessing you either have a japanese background or have stayed there extensively? (or just watched a shit ton of anime. lol) btw, the other day i was perusing fpress and came across an author named anaroriel. she doesn't have much up, but her writing about japan in 'the love curse' reminded me of you, except you focus on describing japanese places and things while she described japanese society. just sayin'.

anyway, enough with the non sequitur review. looking forward to the next chap, as always! ^^
Melissa Norvell
2008-04-27
ch 9,
abuseAnother wonderful chapter. I really like Megumi'sPOv as well. You character's are so interesting.
b
2008-04-22
ch 9,
abuseomg.

sean, why are you insane.

i was definitely NOT expecting that. XD
mandraco
2008-04-22
ch 9,
abuseJust saw this story and had to read it. It's awesome. Can't wait to read more. I'm particularly looking forward to the next Seth bit... for some reason he's my favourite character.

FYI, if you want more reviews you've got anonymous reviews disabled (which is the default FP setting these days... I remember when they didn't even have that setting). You'll get more reviews if you turn it on because sometimes people are too lazy to log in. You can change this by going into your profile to the thing that says Reviews at the left and then Anonymous at the top.

=) Mandraco.
Melissa Norvell
2008-03-09
ch 8,
abuseI rather liked Yuki's POV on a lot of things. His character is very interesting.
b
2008-03-08
ch 8,
abuseman, yuki's pov makes me so depressed 'coz it's so real-- and hits WAY too close to home. (plus, i've gotten used to fluff on fp. x_^;) he still sounds a lot like seth, but i suppose he's a LOT darker since he hasn't had sean to keep him occupied for all of his life.

i wish you'd been more detailed about the dinner with sean! but it also seems very like yuki to totally write off the one nice thing that happened to him that day. ;P i'm sure sean was melting into a little puddle inside. wonder how long he'd been waiting!

and if the chapters keep going in the same order, the next one will be... megumi! yay! (i have a soft spot for him, but i do love every one of your characters :)
b
2008-02-18
ch 7,
abuse1. SEAN, CAN'T YOU SEE THAT SETH IS IN LOVE WITH YOU?! ARGH!
that said, i love the seth angst. i know, it may not be what my mind is thinking it is, but still. the double entendre: that wonderful thing that made the last few harry potter books so enjoyable.

2. something about it may not be grammatically correct, but this is one of my fave lines in the chapter:
"Life is a drug for me, it gets me high everyday, and yet...and yet today, and the past few days, the thing just hadn’t been working for me. I needed a higher dose, damnit!"

3. that was an excruciating wait! but well worth it. ^^

4. in advance-- 'tanjoubi omedetou, megu-chan! i'd like to leave him a yummy birthday cake in his (wonderful!) donations box. what's his favorite flavor? chocolate? vanilla? strawberry? carrot? caramel? none of the above? (and can seth and sean feed it to him? hehe... i'm imagining the most awkward lunch scene ever. -_-;;)
Melissa Norvell
2008-02-16
ch 7,
abusePoor Sean. I hope he gets his troubles figured out.
Melissa Norvell
2008-01-22
ch 6,
abuseWell, thank you for the shout out! I need all the help I can get, lol. But anyway, you've updated a lot since I've read or perhaps its just me. I only update once a week so I tend to miss other's updates who update more frequenlty then I.

However, I do like Seth's narraration. You have a knack for POV.

Thank you for sharing this wonderful story with me.

I shall be back next week to give you another review.
MidnightChaoticPhoenix
2008-01-21
ch 6,
abuseMidnightChaoticPhoenix-a.k.a-Storms-winter ^^
Glad to see that the last chapter is up, I have to admit, I like reading Seth the best out of the four guys.
And 3 reviews already, woot! I'm happy for you, hopefully this will get popular (I'm rooting for ya the whole way!)
...and now I'm going to shut up
Return to Top