Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: Bottling Farewells

taurius1
2008-02-04
ch 1,
abuseThis is a beautiful poem. It's the best of the dozen or so I've read today. :)
KnittingKneedle
2008-01-27
ch 1,
abuseHi I'm taking part in the review marathon! Link on my profile

I liked the first stanza and the goodbye imagery you have.
I like the line about there being 'no lover like the bottom of a bottle-' it's a good insight into an alcoholic- I thought.

I think you go off on a tangent and forget your subject a bit too often for my liking- the stanzas about alcohol are all fine, but some of them are incredibly random

Some of the rhymes you used were a bit tenuous...I don't know if you actaully wanted to make sense...but I have never landed a tail or greeted a jail so I couldn't know what it was like.
Shadows in the Fire
2008-01-23
ch 1,
abuseMy, you don't mind taking over the Just In page, do you? XD

Nice poem, neat style and layout. It was a little scratchy, but that's okay.

-Shadow
Return to Top