Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: The Life of Lily in a Nutshell

Written
2008-02-22
ch 1,
abusethere's a few grammar things here and there, but I like your use of semicolons and dashes... that makes me sound like a huge nerd, doesn't it :)

a few of your words come across as a little awkward to me. 'smelt' made me laugh, because I'm studying chem and smelting is a chemical reduction that you do with metal. I know that you mean it as 'smelled', and you DIDNT make a mistake. it's just that our english usage is different. 'smelt' is more common in british english, and smelled is more common in american, as far as I can tell, though some americans say 'smelt' also. it's kind of a dialect thing...

Okay, don't kill me. I'm just a huge nerd. And I talk a lot?

In my state, we NEVER say 'leant' so that one stuck out a lot. again, not your fault. apparently we just speak weird english where I live.

Please don't kill me for that long rambling bit. I'm sorry! I really like it so far and I hope you write more, so that I have more plot things to talk about instead of rambling on about word usage in different parts of the english speaking world.
figmentation
2008-02-19
ch 1,
abuseCouple things: first paragraph, "summer" shouldn't be capitalised and you don't need a comma before the "and" (pretty much ditto for every ', and' you've got in this piece). In the second paragraph "had departed already - were either" you don't need the 'were'.

Overall, it's an interesting prologue but the thing is, nothing really "happens" per se that I think I'll see later in the story? This could be the first chapter and much longer if you added a little more, particularly about exactly where she was going and what she would be doing that summer. It's a little "empty" as it stands.

That being said, I do look forward to the next chapter and seeing what happens.

figmentation
Return to Top