Share/Save/Bookmark
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: Yuki's Haiku 1

Rosette Kuran
2008-04-14
ch 1,
abuseI really enjoy reading your 15 chapter haiku ^^ They are really unique and have really good idealism to them. Keep it up!
Ygg
2008-04-01
ch 5,
abuseWhat I most miss in your Haiku is some kind of "deep schwung", or the "drama of the natural moment". In my view, a Haiku should be deeply layered with a lot of different (metaphorical) levels of understanding, where the actual words of the Haiku are only the top layer. A Haiku should make you ponder and wonder without ever directing you towards an explanation. The grace of Wonder is not to be explained. I'm not saying I can write Haiku like this, but it's just my view on what a genuine Haiku should be about.
Ygg
2008-04-01
ch 4,
abuseThe last line is tough, and fits very well with the title!
Ygg
2008-04-01
ch 3,
abuseQuestions indeed.. A bit too bland for my taste.
Ygg
2008-04-01
ch 2,
abuseAlthough the imagery is definitely great, I didn't like the successive adjectives in the last line ("silent, sad quiet beauty"). It kind of breaks the internal flow.. The idea is great though!
Ygg
2008-04-01
ch 1,
abusePretty dark and haunting (especially due to the last line)!
Return to Top