Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: The Rancher's Daughter

Wrider
2008-04-10
ch 1,
abuseFirst off, a few little grammatical/typo errors I noticed:
"Joe kept whipping" - wiping
"she handed him the bear" - beer
"anger in her ton" - tone
"Tris brook his nose" -broke
"you have already meet her too" - met
Also, it seemed a little hard to follow at some points. I'm not sure how ...that's probably not much help to you though...

Overall, I enjoyed it and think it is working up to a good and interesting story. Am awaiting updates!
Cthulhu Is An Awesome God
2008-04-09
ch 1,
abuseI like the concept very much. A modern western about an old fashioned range war fought with fists instead of six-guns, and by some tough-as-nails cowgirl, sounds mighty fine. I think you need a bit more action to start though, instead of just some guy asking who she is. Maybe show Tristan administering a bloody beat down on some rednecks or something. Also, for this kind of story, I think a definite time and place should be stated. Montana, 1993 or something, maybe in a characters dialogue or right at the beginning would cement the setting and make it much better. Well, I'm looking forward to more and I can't wait to see some awe-inspiring beat-downs.
Return to Top