Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: Torn rose
Esther Jade 2008-04-20 . chapter 1
I like the "torn, scarlet rose". It's quite a simple description but clear. It's not a big issue but I think it would improve the poem to change the comma at the end of the second line to a colon. A colon is often used to introduce an explanation, which is why I think it would be appropriate here.

- Esther, currently reviewing for the Review Game's Review Marathon (link in my profile)
fatbird33 2008-04-19 . chapter 1
nice:)
Lady-CheshireXIII 2008-04-12 . chapter 1
first line should have five syllables. it only has four. but it is a very nice poem, except for the syllables. you could say scarlet instead of red to make it right. but you don't have to.
just giving some constructive critisism.
Thoughtful Silence 2008-04-09 . chapter 1
I really like the vivid imagery of this (I mean, what's better to use than a red rose) and how it doesn't follow the traditional haiku format. Though I didn't like the use of 'resembles'... that's kinda implied automatically... but I still liked this. Good job!

-Silence
Return to Top