Share/Save/Bookmark
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: Without her

Almsivi
2008-06-03
ch 1,
abuseThis was a powerful poem, and I could relate to it - I think almost anyone can. Good job.
simpleplan13
2008-05-19
ch 1,
abuseI feel empty; a part of me missing... semi-colons separate two sentences and the second if is not a sentence. It's missing an is

It’s now you’re choice to walk the way you want... your

She was mines for so long,.. mine

I got confused with who the you is in relation to the her. Other than that I liked it. I liked the format especially. Nicely done.
a silenced revolution
2008-04-25
ch 1,
abuseThe sorrow and emotion is well conveyed, and I like the directness.

However, in another way, this seems too plain and unpoetic. I think more imagery/details/metaphor would improve and give this more impact.

'It's now you're choice to walk the way you want.'
--should be 'your choice'.

The 'I no longer wish to live' at the end sounds just too cliché to me.

Over all, I think this has potential in the idea and the feelings, but needs more to make it great.

-Adrian
lamia morosa
2008-04-24
ch 1,
abusethis is really good...i liked it because it reminded me of my own writing...you are a really good writer...keep up the good work! Lamia morosa
Williamchan87
2008-04-22
ch 1,
abuseMust someone really close to you, I also can relate to this.
Princess-anna57
2008-04-22
ch 1,
abuseI totally feel this poem and can relate. Well said. Always be positive and keep writing.

~Anna~ ^_^
Return to Top