Share/Save/Bookmark
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: Challenge Thirty Five - Reviews: Page 1 of 2

Stormie
2008-06-01
ch 2, anon.
abuseStormie...is voting. All hail. And rain. And snow. And I'm sleep deprived, how could you tell?

Best: Myriad
Originality: Chiomi and Myriad
Mechanics: Blackcat

Fantastic stories, you lot!
MatthewPaul
2008-05-31
ch 2,
abuseOrig: Myriad
Mech: Chiomi
Best: Myriad
PandaKnight
2008-05-31
ch 4, anon.
abuseM... they were all awesome, and I had time to give better readthroughs than I normally do (with about a third of the usual submission count), but here's the verdict:

Mechanics: BlackCat
Originality: Chiomi
Best: Myriad
Jane Ellecot
2008-05-30
ch 1,
abuseOriginallity: BlackCat
Mechanics: Chiomi
Best: Myriad
~Jane
Myriadragon
2008-05-30
ch 1,
abuseNot much to choose from this month, but:

Mech--BlackCat
Orig--Chiomi
Best--Chiomi
Myriadragon
2008-05-30
ch 2,
abuseIt's better lengthened, though it still needs to be longer. And I still love the ending.
Fenrir
2008-05-29
ch 1, anon.
abuseMechanics: Chiomi
Originality: BlackCat
Best: Myriad
Washi Chiisai
2008-05-28
ch 1,
abuseRatings! :)

Originality: Myriad
Mechanics: Chiomi
Best: Myriad
Motoko
2008-05-26
ch 1, anon.
abuseBest: Myriad
Originality: Chiomi
Mechanics: BlackCat
ImagineMe
2008-05-26
ch 4,
abuseI loved all three stories and here are my votes :)
Originality: BlackCat
Mechanics: Chiomi
Best: Myriad
Lenari Soto
2008-05-26
ch 4,
abuseI like your narrator's voice quite a bit; it's got character. I'm also very interested in seeing where you go with this series.

Voting time!

Originality: this one's a toughie, as we had two pretty similar general concepts going on, but Myriad's won me over.

Mechanics: Chiomi

Best: Myriad
Lenari Soto
2008-05-26
ch 3,
abuseLOVE. SO MUCH LOVE. I'm also amused that Avery/Avim's sister is named Rhian, as I'm planning on naming my daughter Rihan. :D

Basically? I cannot wait for the next installment. Amazing job as always!
Lenari Soto
2008-05-26
ch 2,
abuse...just the fact that it's called the Tower of Truth, Justice, and Spandex makes my life! And I very much like the interaction between Sabrina and Taranis. Basically? I love this. I don't even have enough brain power to say anything else atm. ;)
watchdog
2008-05-25
ch 1,
abuseI just read the submitions for C-35 and here are my votes. It was hard to chose but these are the ones that spoke to me.

Mechanics- Being Tied to a Bed Isn’t All Bad When You’ve Got Your Own Personal Knight-in-Shining-Armour By: BlackCat.

From a technical standpoint this story was the one that I in my limited literary knowlege thought was the best put together. This story would have been the best overall if not for the main chaercter "Maddy". I think that Maddy is a male, but he reads like a female and that can be a little confusing at times. I beleive this to be a qurk of the chaercter and not the story itself.

Originalty- The Kalani (I) By Myriad.

I was very impresed with the whole new world that was invented for this story and the seemless way it was intergrated into the modern world. I would like to read more and see where it goes.

Best Read- Again The Kalani (I) by Myriad.

The story just flowed from one point to the next and I could not stop. I had to know what hapens next. A real page turner. I can only hope to be this good one day.
henred5
2008-05-24
ch 1,
abuse—Mechanics: The Kalani (I) By Myriad

—Originality: Tower Stories Part Two: Sabrina and Taranis By Chiomi

—Best: The Kalani (I) By Myriad
Return to Top