Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: Obsidian
Huddled-In-The-Corner 2008-07-31 . chapter 1
I think you did a fabulous job. The emotional rage in the song really worked for it. I liked how it all kind of fit together. The only thing that I could say is that I think it would be better as a poem than I song, yet I bet the rhythm that would go with this song would be interesting.
RedWheeler 2008-05-18 . chapter 1
Finally getting around to reviewing some stuff, although I don't know how much I'll get through. At least half of what you have uploaded recently, that's what I'm aiming for.

Anyway, I had to look up what Obsidian meant. Heh. It was one of those times where you swear you know the word (and I did XD) but you can't place it in your head. Just thought I'd bring that up, I don't know why I was doubting what I thought originally.

Didn't see any spelling or grammar errors. At least none that I saw when I was reading through, so if there are some... I didn't find them.

My favourite part(s) were near the end: "So why can’t we wake? From this beautiful nightmare! My knees are scraped! From crawling nowhere!" and "I still miss the light! And your crystal laughter! So I swear I’ll try! To see what comes after..." That general section (can't think of the word), hopefully you know what I mean, stuck out in comparison to the song for me.

Nice job. Only criticism I have is that in some parts the rhyming seemed a tad bit forced. A tad. That's it. XP
Subsequent Cross 2008-05-07 . chapter 1
I love this. Something about it is catchy, and the repetition of 'obsidian' flows. It fits.

If this song ever gets sung, I definitely wanna hear it. *grin*
Wilkem18 2008-05-07 . chapter 1
not bad at all. i really enjoy it. the emotional range covered is also very good. and you're right. the best songs usually come during an emotional period. keep up the good work.
Return to Top