 xfail 2008-07-13 . chapter 1I'm sorry to say you won't be getting much helpful critique from me, for I'm in awe. When I read the explanation I was a little unsure about it, but you certainly did redeem yourself! I'm surprised how well it flowed; also, the meaning was intact even when lines were placed in what could have become a haphazard position. My favourite lines were "For a hollow heart so full of halls,
A day undoes a month of walls."
Simply brilliant. I find it impossible to criticize a thing about it. |
 outinarizona 2008-06-29 . chapter 3This part --
Saccharine dreams, may syrup speak
Over bitter truth, tonight.
Lies have never been so sweet;
Icing flows, a milky stream,
Despairing for the bitter light.
Icing flows, a milky stream,
Taste and see that it is good.
You, too, shall learn how we recite:
-- I notice the line "Icing flows, a milky stream," is the 2nd in the other stanzas, whereas this is the 4th and 6th lines in this rather long one. It feels like it needs a break in there somewhere. I'm not sure if you want go so far as swapping things around to match the others, as I don't know what your intention was for this section... |
 outinarizona 2008-06-29 . chapter 2Last stanza, this first line...
"Who who paided my way that I might be"
I'm not sure that's what you meant? Doesn't make sense to me... |
 outinarizona 2008-06-29 . chapter 1"It always seems I come this far to slip."
-- Can we say 'slogan?' Because that's was that line was to me for most of my life and I HATED it so much. It kicks me back down sometimes, but I've been successful, for a while, in breaking free of that pattern.
I like it. A little rough in spots, but it adds to the meaning. I don't think it'd work if it were perfect. Very catchy. My mantra of the week. |
 SpazzyBatty95 2008-06-28 . chapter 1I have to say that I was not really big on the form of the poetry, but honestly that is just one person's opinion. I just think it could do with a little tweaking... |
|