Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: Son of Elsariy
Mercyette 2008-10-29 . chapter 1
I really like how you managed to immediately draw the reader in with you intense scene at the beginning. It really helps since your chapter is rather lengthly. That way the reader doesn't got too side-tracked while reading. (I suffer from the same thing - too much detail at once). But it isn't necessarily a bad thing.

One thing you might consider doing is to divid the chapter contents up a bit into other chapters, that way it wouldn't seem too intimidating to the reader. I understand, though, that in reality chapters that are in print aren't that short. Just something to consider. Also, at the end I probably would have used italics rather than parenthesis, but that's just a personal preference.

Overall a nice job!
october lies 2008-10-26 . chapter 1
this is so long - i understand wanting to write longer chapters or so, but (nearly) 10,0 words? for a standalone/one shot/first chapter? that's way too much, and i don't like that. it obviously can be split in half or three parts to be a two/three chaptered story. another thing that i didn't like is the way that i can't really feel any emotion in this. a lot of the dialogue in here doesn't seem like it's stressed to it's full potential of emotion. for instance - the part where jadon's father informs jadon that earth is not their home. it could easily be drawn out and intensified, but right now, i'm hardly feeling any emotion when i (or at least i hope) should be feeling a lot.
Written 2008-10-19 . chapter 1
right from the start, you deliver... "punchy" prose, if that makes sense. I mean it in the good way. like, the words create vivid images and really set the scene. I like that, because sometimes in sci-fi, things can be hard to follow :)

I also like how confident you are with the setting, even though it's very futuristic- it gives us the feeling that it's real.

["Oh come on, J!" scoffed Vince, the lance's second-in-command. "We totally took them by surprise! That one walker didn't have a chance, and we brought the roof down on top of his friends before they could even get into the picture. An inspired idea, if you ask me.”]

uh oh, famous last words? haha. I don't know, but Jadon's worries seem ... foreboding.

the banter between the lancemates seems really realistic! good work.

the action scene that follows is well done, and this is coming from someone who really can't follow most action scenes. I like that everything is clear and concise.

and then the reveal that they were just playing a game! I loved that. I wasn't exactly expecting it, but it was well done.

Jadon is very ** his team mates. eep.

Sezja is an interesting character. I wonder what his dad and the other man were discussing?

aha. interesting that you made their "origin" story the story of babel. your main character's resistance to the truth is very believable.

and then the action packed scene with the mother's death has just the right tone. I didn't really like the extended "noo" part, because it seemed a tad trite, but it wasn't bad.

whew, that was a whirlwind read! great job.
SyMph0Ny Of cOloRS 2008-10-19 . chapter 1
It's interesting and draws the reader in. I like the futuristic effect and the originality. I don't really read alot of stories on fictionpress like what I've read so far so kudos to you. I'm excited to see what happens next so update fast mkay?
Return to Top