| Reviews for Yuki's Haiku 3 |
|---|
Erlkoenigin 5/5/09 . chapter 3a good haiku! compet with mind would be a poem of its own accord, |
Erlkoenigin 5/5/09 . chapter 2the headline is interesting, a very beautiful poem! |
Erlkoenigin 5/5/09 . chapter 1great! I like the dual meaning of final! |
Sercus Kaynine 4/26/09 . chapter 20Reviewing from the Review Game's Review Marathon! *link on profile* I like the idea of this piece. It is one everyone can learn from. I didn't like the particular questions chosen to be used in the poem, though, because they're not the ones that make for great thinking. |
Sercus Kaynine 4/26/09 . chapter 19Reviewing from the Review Game's Review Marathon! *link on profile* I liked the contrast in this poem. It made for a nice flow. I also liked the personal way the poem was presented. It was touching. |
Sercus Kaynine 4/26/09 . chapter 18Reviewing from the Review Game's Review Marathon! *link on profile* I liked the opening phrase because it was one I was familiar with and could understand. I didn't like the theme of this poem because it it's overused. |
Sercus Kaynine 4/26/09 . chapter 17Reviewing from the Review Game's Review Marathon! *link on profile* I like the message of this poem. it brings about hope. I liked the way you phrased the second line because it was beautiful. |
Sercus Kaynine 4/26/09 . chapter 16Reviewing from the Review Game's Review Marathon! *link on profile* I like the moment presented here. It's very real, if also very sad. I didn't like how you kept saying the same thing over in over again in different words in the second line, though. It cut off the flow of the poem. |
Sercus Kaynine 4/26/09 . chapter 15Reviewing from the Review Game's Review Marathon! *link on profile* I liked the icy imagery used here. It made the poem feel cold. I also liked how the poem made me picture a sword without ever mentioning blades or steel. It was a very sneaky and smart way to present the idea. |
Sercus Kaynine 4/26/09 . chapter 14Reviewing from the Review Game's Review Marathon! *link on profile* I like the idea for this poem because it was very clever and easy to understand. I also like the theme because it represents a moment every can relate with. |
Sercus Kaynine 4/26/09 . chapter 13Reviewing from the Review Game's Review Marathon! *link on profile* I love the open-ended idea to this poem because it gave the reader a moment to use her mind. I like you word choices here because they went together well. |
Sercus Kaynine 4/26/09 . chapter 12Reviewing from the Review Game's Review Marathon! *link on profile* I like the idea of this piece because it represents a moment everyone celebrates and loves. I also liked you words choice. It gave the poem an original feel. |
Sercus Kaynine 4/26/09 . chapter 11Reviewing from the Review Game's Review Marathon! *link on profile* I love the variety of metaphors used here. They gave the poem a lovely image. I also liked how you got so many ideas across in so few words. It gave the poem an original feel. |
Sercus Kaynine 4/26/09 . chapter 10Reviewing from the Review Game's Review Marathon! *link on profile* I love the clash of the idea and the words used- the idea is chaos, but the words are peaceful. It gave the poem a contradictory feel. I also liked the ending line because it brought the piece to a nice halt after introducing the general idea. |
Sercus Kaynine 4/26/09 . chapter 9Reviewing from the Review Game's Review Marathon! *link on profile* I like how you focused on just the freezing flower idea because it gave the poem it's own identity. I also liked the alliteration used in this poem because it made the words flow smoothly. |