Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: Formal Challenge 05
Catseye*Rose 2009-02-28 . chapter 1
Mechanics: Faelein

Originality: Mari

Best: Chiomi

It was hard to choose o.o
Fenrir 2009-02-19 . chapter 1
Mechanics: Chiomi
Originality: Mari
Best: Faelein
Fenrir 2009-02-19 . chapter 6
The ending does seem to come out of the blue; you might expand the piece, to give a little more build-up. Otherwise, I thought the story worked really well; it has a really vivid culture, which I'd like to see more of.
Fenrir 2009-02-19 . chapter 5
I really liked this. You do stylistic omissions - leaving out things which aren't relevant to the story - very neatly, and the title is a cool subversion of the stereotypical 'tin soldier.' ... And I'm a sucker for cute stories. :)
Fenrir 2009-02-19 . chapter 4
I'd like to see more of this too; it seems like there's a lot more to the characters than is shown in this scene, which transcends the stereotypical 'choose your spouse or your lover' situation well.
faelein 2009-02-17 . chapter 1
Mechanics: Laelah
Originality: Chiomi
Best: Laelah
Chiomi 2009-02-15 . chapter 1
Originality: Mari
Mechanics: BlackCat
Best: Faelein
Chiomi 2009-02-15 . chapter 3
It's an interesting concept, but the language is confusingly used.
Fenrir 2009-02-11 . chapter 3
I think this is a really interesting piece, in terms of plot. The style, though, can be a little confusing - you juxtapose a lot of archaic and modern phrasing, which makes the narrator's voice a bit hard to follow.
Fenrir 2009-02-11 . chapter 2
I liked this; the more morbid versions of fairy tales tend to be entertaining, and I think it translated pretty well into a modern setting.

The ending felt a bit rushed, though, especially Camilla's feelings - Camilla was probably the most fleshed out character in most of the piece, but she's almost cut out of the ending. Likewise, it would have been interesting to see more of Sunshine's motivations - both in ignoring Jason, and in general.
Chiomi 2009-02-10 . chapter 4
Yay! Fun story, despite the angst. Gay fairies is the best, most awful pun ever. I'd love to see a continuation of this.
Chiomi 2009-02-10 . chapter 5
Really, really cute story.
Chiomi 2009-02-10 . chapter 6
This was really interesting. I liked that the world was so vivid. It could have been longer, and I'd like to see more of it, but Clairi was an interesting character.
Return to Top