Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: Withering
Samana 2009-09-14 . chapter 1
wow. wonderful expression of a dominating will to be submissive. I like the symbolism of the bird greatly, and the line "Wet feathers and bloody claws are flaws only I could love." stuck with resonance to my core. great work. the last line rang true as always. love this piece. favorited.
Xerophyte 2009-09-14 . chapter 1
Usually I try to give a critique of a poem in a review. But I honestly can't think of anything you could have possibly done better.

Utterly beautiful.
Isca 2009-09-01 . chapter 1
"You starve yourself in heart and stomach both." Your use of the word 'starve' here is very creative and refreshing. I love that one can 'starve' oneself of food and love.

"Those I could love in you." Aww, that's so beautiful! I like that the speaker loves the 'flaws' of this other person.

The 'tether' and 'indulge' parts reminded me of the myth regarding Prometheus. :)
George Doctanian 2009-08-29 . chapter 1
Ah sweet romance, you use amazing detail, I really like the starting sentence with the ripped wing bit. You are a amazing poet, no spelling mistakes and you have the pace downpat. It kept me reading. Th format was also very well done, while not in a "traditional" format it was beautiful. I'm not crazy about romance, but this is a great poem. I couldn't see any flaws.


In all a 9.5 out of 10.
Kate Marshall 2009-08-29 . chapter 1
Your word choices were so good! I liked "love" in the first line a lot. I thought it set the tone well. And "tethers", "indulge", "conquest", and "scale" were all very powerful and vivid; not stale or uninteresting. ;)

Descriptions. I had a clear picture in my head while I read this. The descriptions in this were well done.

"Wet feathers and bloody claws are flaws only I could love." Wonderful internal rhyme! 'claws/flaws' added a more poetic feeling to the piece. Nicely done!

(And the exclamation points were a good touch, by the way.)
Inkspilled 2009-08-29 . chapter 1
Very nice. Strong and moving, with a very nice ending.
Simple, and surprising, in the good way.
I like it. It paints the picture of desperation and longing nicely.
Red Dynamite 2009-08-28 . chapter 1
WOAH. i think i actually got the chills while reading this. your imagery is incredible and the subject matter is heart-wrenching. this really made me think about whether or not i do things that make other people feel this was about me...

my favorite lines were:
"Wet feathers and bloody claws are flaws only I could love."
and
"Just take refuge, use me, / Scale these walls, oh lover of stone,"

really, really amazing piece. i hope you write more. :)

peace,
red.
MoonlightRouge 2009-08-27 . chapter 1
I like your poem incredible words you use
the beginning is beautiful what has ripped your wing, love
I'm not much of a romantic but i know a good poem when i see one very nice keep it up
katietheunicorn 2009-08-27 . chapter 1
Great job! I love the refrences and imagrey you presented here, they really bring it to life. I could really see this as though an actual woman were begging a man to love her in return.
I find no major flaws, and not many minor ones either. I have to search to find them! *gasp!*
Aiden Payne 2009-08-26 . chapter 1
very powerful and moving in such a symbolic way, this was excellent. Great job! :)
East-0f-Eden 2009-08-26 . chapter 1
I think you should have put this under love poems. While it contains no compliments. It's beautiful and full of love because it's full of your hope for him/her.
Alice World 2009-08-26 . chapter 1
I really liked the desperation that the speaker uses to try to persuade the person to love them. There was loads of feelingin this poem, and I loved it.
=]
Return to Top