oh darn, not what I expected, but kinda suckish and good at the same time. I hope nothing's too wrong with Nolan. He was starting to grow on me

You definitely are the Queen of Cliffhangers, but your also the Queen of writing awesome chapters! Loved this one (even without Shaul...lol) Update soon please!

Please update as soon as possible! Your awesome but it sucks that this chapter is really short. And please update soon! I love your stories!

hate cliff hangers so much, but loved the chap :)

i was kinda of surprised to know about cel's birth... i hope nolan will be ok... i have a feeling that cel will heal him

NO

how can you do this to your faithful readers! NO.

yes. here i am suffering in deep agony while you alone knows what shall happen to our dear heroine...and Nolan. NO i want to read moree!

bring back shaul! hehehe keep up the good work. and please please end my pain soon

I loved it.

Shortest Review Ever.

.

.

.

.

.

Joking! I could never do that! :P

That was great! But I'm REALY missing Shaul now. Shaul. Shaul. Shaul. Oh, god, im going crazy.

I go crazy ever time i read this anyway.

And WELL DONE! It's been straight 2 weeks. :D

So when is the next chappy coming?

And wow about Celeste! I couldn't believe it! Mhmm...no, actually, i did believe it. Lol.

PLEASE update faster, within this week, if possible? It's my half term, and I NEED Celestia of the Thorns! PLEASE!

PRETTY PRETTY PRETTY PLEASE!

omgmomgomgomgomg!

you are far too good at this cliffhanger thing!

.

several shockers in that chapter!

update soon!

OMG! You're not the Queen! You're Eviletta! Haha, that was so not fair!I had been waiting for this chapter with so much enthusiasm, and that's how you repay it? With a cliffy! It's just pure evilness, dear!

But i like the chapter!I would have never thought that Celestia was actually adopted...hm...interesting. I wonder how that is going to effect story overall?

D'you know what? I kinda think you're like amazing!

P.S. Congratulations! I know you didnt mention it in your french-like AN but I still wanted to congratulate you about what you had said a while ago! I hope you're happy with the news!

Please upload really soon!

Thanks!

i miss shaul, even though its still fun to read about the rest of the characters. ;)can't wait for more.

Oi! Nice chapter no?

I was laughing all the way up till the end, when I was confused, and slightly worried... Poor Nolan...

Rather enjoyable beginning, _

And how strange that Celeste is adopted, and is the actual inheritor of the Isle of the Thorns anyway... o_O

Good Luck!

KT{ImmortalIncarnate}

Hiya there! I read your other stories a while ago and I loved them. I think this story is just brilliant and I can't wait to read more. So please update soon and good luck with the story!

Too lazy to log in. Short chapter but any update for this story is a good update.

I'm really looking forward to reading about Shaul's reaction to her leaving. I miss the interaction between the two.

Fair to say you're pretty good at leaving us cliffhangers )

It's like one question answered and another pops up! Partially why I'm following this story like a little puppy after chewy snacks.

great chapter! very revealing, and i loved all the character interactions :)