O.O Okay, I don't read horror that much, ((actually, not at all)), and this was just creepy. Although, I'm actually kind of glad it didn't have that much descriptions, other wise it'll give me nightmares.
Things aren't always what they seem...

That was good, but it could have been more descriptive. I loved the reasoning behind the number of fingers.

read something simular to this but always got me going love clown stories hate clowni lol just a question why would she put it at the bottom of the stiar case and not in her room? also wouldnt she bring it up to her mom if it happened more then once? lol

I've heard another version of this story where a boy finds a photo of a pretty girl wearing a baseball cap and doing the peace sign. Then, the next night, he heard a girl laughing outside and he climbed out his window to find the source, but there was nothing. That happened for a couple more nights, then he disappeared and all his parents found was the picture of the girl and she was holding up three fingers.

I like this take on it, though. I think that it could've been really good if you had more detail, though. It's not really that scary.

This is a interesting story in a short 9 lines. Slightly cliched but otherwise interesting.

That was actually kind of funny. "Three kills."

I think that the idea and the plot of the story are good, and scary, but I think it could have been much much better had you gone into a little bit more detail. Often times the thrill of a good horror story is in the suspense. Regardless, write on!