Verse 1

I keep on going back

To the past and making a list of the things we lack.

Starting with trust

And ending with the misunderstanding that broke us.

And while I'm at it,

The pieces just won't fit,

And I cannot help but keep thinking

How it would have went

If things were different….

Chorus

You should have been the right guy

And I should have known!

That I was in love-

Our feelings should have shown!

And you'd ask me out,

I'd say yes without a doubt

And then sounds of laughter,

Our happily ever after.

Curtain's closing; it'd all fade to black….

I just keep on going back….

Verse 2

Now look at what I did.

I didn't even realize I was in love, I was being stupid.

You found someone else

And that was the full stop to our story, everything failed.

And know that I try

To hide the tears in my eyes

But I cannot stop thinking about

How it would have went

If things were different…

Chorus

You should have been the right guy

And I should have known!

That I was in love-

Our feelings should have shown!

And you'd ask me out,

I'd say yes without a doubt

And then sounds of laughter,

Our happily ever after.

Curtain's closing; it'd all fade to black….

I just keep on going back….

Bridge

They said true love can overcome anything.

I know my love is true.

So that leaves me here to… point the finger at you.

I kept on painting pictures of a fairytale.

Then a wave just crushed it like it was a sand-castle.

You had no feelings for me, whatsoever.

Why do they all call me clever? (Huh!)

I am a fool, fool, fool

Cause I still keep on thinking

How it would have went

If things were different….

Chorus

You should have been the right guy

And I should have known!

That I was in love-

Our feelings should have shown!

And you'd ask me out,

I'd say yes without a doubt

And then sounds of laughter,

Our happily ever after.

Curtain's closing; it'd all fade to black….

I just keep on going back….