Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Fractured Illusion's Forums » The Review Game Topic Subscription

Forums » The Review Game » The Review Game: Stories - Easy Fix
Author Post
Fractured Illusion
Topic: The Review Game: Stories - Easy Fix
This is the place to come if you want reviews for a story, and the review type is "easy fix", aka a simple review.

You can use whichever RG you like: Stories or Multi-chap. Just because your story is multi-chap does not mean you cannot use the Story RGs. These RGs are all voluntary.

For Review Game rules, go to "Read this first!".

Moving on, this is the basic structure of the Review Game:

Person 1 says: Review "My Lucky Dream"!

Person 2 says: Ok, I reviewed it. So can the next person please review "Stereotypes" or "Window"?

Person 3 says: Done (I did "Window"), so can the next person review "Stranger"? Thanks.

For Stories Easy Fix, your review needs to fulfill these requirements, otherwise you will not be seen as someone who has fulfilled their obligation and you can thus not participate.

REVIEW REQUIREMENTS:

You need to state one thing you liked and *why*, and one thing you didn't like/could be improved, and *why*. Giving more feedback is not prohibited, but giving less than this is. Flaming is also prohibited. Being constructive is not.

If you absolutely can only find good or less good things to say, then please state two things you liked and *why*, or two things you didn't like and *why*. The review will be seen as invalid otherwise.

STORY TO REVIEW:

As the Review Game is a continuation of a previous thread, the last participant there was Imalefty, and she said either Princess, E Flat or Happiness would do. So review either of those according to the requirements, post that you reviewed and what story you want reviewed.

LET THE GAMES BEGIN!

#1 Nov 11th 2007, 10:55am . Edited Mar 03rd, 1:58am
soojinyeh
Reviewed Princess-good idea. Please do Goddess-it is finally done!
#2 Nov 11th 2007, 1:32pm
Imalefty
princess or e flat, please! :)

-Lefty

#3 Nov 23rd 2007, 5:09pm
Barbados
reviewed E Flat - brilliant concept.

Dawn of Oblivion, please. :)

#4 Nov 26th 2007, 3:28am
Wes Sheaborn
Done.

Somebody do Slate.

Note that chapters 1 and 2 are actually supposed to be the combined prologue, but I split them because of length. Just in case you read one and think it seems incomplete or abrupt.

#5 Dec 07th 2007, 12:37pm
Imalefty
done slate. would suggest it. :)

princess, please! (and if you physically CAN'T review it, then do any of my other stories... XD) thanks!

-Lefty

#6 Dec 10th 2007, 7:21pm
Narc
Reviewed a couple chapters of Princess (kind of just using this as an excuse to review it, since I wanted to read more of it anyways). Roanoke please.
#7 Dec 16th 2007, 12:02pm
Dexterity
Did the first chapter of Roanoke (would do more if it isn't like...1am). Please review "Beyond the Horizon"
#8 Dec 18th 2007, 12:02am
soojinyeh
Reviewed Beyond the horizon. Goddess, please.
#9 Dec 18th 2007, 8:20am
moonlight.dream
I reviewed Goddess =)

Please review For the Love of Music, Play on.

#10 Dec 19th 2007, 11:27pm
Dexterity
reviewed "For the Love of Music, Play on"

please review "Beyond the Horizon"

#11 Dec 20th 2007, 12:16pm
Imalefty
done beyond the horizon.

princess please! :)

-Lefty

#12 Dec 21st 2007, 9:25am
Terrance Riverdarb
I have done Princess.

I would prefer if ya'll did Plain Sight. I'm not the boss f you however, so just pick one which screams out at ya.

#13 Dec 22nd 2007, 4:59am
Imalefty
done plain sight.

would appreciate reviews on princess, but if you can't, then... any others please... :)

-Lefty

#14 Dec 22nd 2007, 11:51am
Rejlan
I reviewed Princess, please review Demons Within
#15 Dec 31st 2007, 7:05am
soojinyeh
Did Demons Within. 2007 Fiction Awards please.
#16 Dec 31st 2007, 11:32pm
Imalefty
reviewed fiction awards.

princess, please. :)

-Lefty

#17 Jan 04th, 3:45pm
Narc
In hopes of getting the review game ball rolling again ... done princess.

And now I have total review game fiction domination! Mwahahaha!

Err, that is to say--Roanoke, please.

#18 Jan 09th, 10:03am
Imalefty
done roanoke. :)

princess, please! thanks!

-Lefty

#19 Jan 12th, 3:09pm
KnittingKneedle
princess= done...super job!

Last Summer please/thank-you

#20 Jan 14th, 1:03am
Chewyy the Moofin
Last Summer done!

Loved it.

Third Wheel's Encumbrance please. =D Thanks!

#21 Jan 19th, 7:55am
concerto49
done.

Elegant Emotions Thank you.

#22 Jan 19th, 11:38pm
Chewyy the Moofin
Done.

"Once" or "Keep Breathing" please. Thanks!

#23 Jan 20th, 10:00am
Rejlan
Read Once.

An excellent start.

Please review Demons Within or The Pearl of Sorrow.

#24 Jan 20th, 11:00am
Narc
--Off Topic--

Rejlan, I'm not a moderator, but since I'm the first one to check it out, I should probably bring it up. Even the Easy Fix forum does have requirements for the review, and unfortunately, your review of 'Once' doesn't fulfill those requirements. Please read the first post in this topic thoroughly. You need to state one thing you liked and -why- you liked that thing, and also one thing you didn't like and -why- you didn't like. I believe if you couldn't find anything you didn't like, you can give four separate things that you liked and your reasons why. Right now all you've said is that you like the sentence structure and emotions.

Not a big deal. You can review again to fulfill those requirements and just repost once you've done that.

--End Off Topic--

Story to be reviewed should still be "Once" or "Keep Breathing" by Chewyy.

#25 Jan 20th, 11:59am . Edited Jan 20th, 12:02pm
Rejlan
I'm sorry for not fulfilling the requirements. I can't write a new review, so I will send a new review by private messaging.

It should be "Once" and "Keep Breathing" by Chewyy the moffin.

#26 Jan 20th, 12:22pm
Fractured Illusion
--- OFF TOPIC! ---

@Narc

I appreciate your watchful eyes. Thank you.

@Rej

Well, you CAN write a new review, though for the Keep Breathing story. You can do that if you wish.

--- END OF OFF TOPIC! ---

Until then,

"Once" or "Keep Breathing" by Chewyy the moffin

#27 Jan 20th, 12:35pm
Tabrias
Once has been reviewed

Please review Paper Cranes or Without Reason

#28 Jan 20th, 5:43pm
Erocdrah
I have done Without Reason.

You may do anyhing of mine that you so please.

:P

#29 Jan 20th, 7:16pm
concerto49
Did Different People.

Elegant Emotions Thank you.

#30 Jan 20th, 9:05pm
Tabrias
Elegant Emotions done and I plan to do it again =)

Paper cranes please

#31 Jan 21st, 11:50am
Chewyy the Moofin
Paper Cranes done.

Reminds me of the ones I made.

Once, please! Thanks.

#32 Jan 21st, 2:11pm
concerto49
Done once.

Elegant Emotions Thanks.

#33 Jan 21st, 3:47pm
Narc
Done Elegant Emotions.

Roanoke, please.

#34 Jan 24th, 6:41am
Dexterity
Done Roanoke second chapter.

"Willing Tool" please.

#35 Jan 24th, 11:03pm
Mercyette
Read Willing Tool! Very good, by the way! ;) Can someone plese read Leaning Towards Love or A Small Mustard Seed next? Appreaciate it!
#36 Jan 26th, 12:34am
Dexterity
Did first chapter of "Leaning Towards Love"

"Willing Tool" please

#37 Jan 26th, 11:13am
Unbeknownst
Done "Willing Tool"--though I forgot to add, the word you're looking for is "sew" and not "sow"--"sow" means to plant, where "sew" is--well, needle and thread.

Um. Either of the two WIPs ("Illusions," which is a rough-draft, dystopian fiction meets fantasy setting, or "Typical," which is a re-write of an earlier story of mine, and is satire) are fair game. I'd really prefer comments on those two, but the short stories and stuff are OK as well. :)

EDIT: *Are* fair game, not "is fair game."

#38 Jan 26th, 5:10pm . Edited Jan 26th, 5:11pm
Soul Decay
Done

'Angels of the Past'

or

'Perfect Solider'

thanks =)

#39 Jan 26th, 5:39pm . Edited Jan 26th, 5:39pm
Imalefty
reviewed "typical." funny. :)

princess, please. (and if not... then any other story will do.) thanks!

-Lefty

#40 Jan 26th, 5:42pm
Imalefty
agh, it happened again. okay, so... unbeknownst has to review soul decay, and my story is up.

princess or anything else, please. thanks!

-Lefty

#41 Jan 26th, 5:43pm
Mercyette
Reviewed Princess. Very cute, by the way! "Leaning Towards Love" or "A Small Mustard Seed", please!
#42 Jan 26th, 5:51pm
Unbeknownst
Done "Angels of the Past" (first chapter).

"Typical" or "Illusions" (or anything you feel like reviewing).

EDIT: OK, after re-reading the rules for clarification (didn't realise I'd been reviewed twice, oops), also did "A Small Mustard Seed" (very cute :)).

#43 Jan 26th, 6:03pm . Edited Jan 26th, 6:16pm
Mercyette
Read Allusions. Very interesting! "Leaning Towards Love" is perferred, but what ever strikes your fancy is cool with me! Thanks
#44 Jan 26th, 6:51pm
Dexterity
Did second chapter of "Leaning Towards Love"

"Willing Tool" please; if not, then my other story is fine too

#45 Jan 26th, 9:10pm
Kaiyako Kagami
Just did "Willing Tool"

Please review "The Nerd That Everyones After...wait what?!" or "Encounters of The Living"

Thank you.

#46 Jan 28th, 7:11am
Mercyette
Read the "Nerd That Everyone's After..." Good start! Please review "Leaning Towards Love" next if you can! Thanks!
#47 Jan 28th, 11:17am
Dexterity
Done third chapter of "Leaning Towards Love"

"Willing Tool" next if you can, otherwise my other story is fine too

#48 Jan 29th, 11:14am
Kaiyako Kagami
Hey,

I just reviewed "Beyond The Horizon" by Dexterity. An enjoyable read that I recommend.

Would someone please review "Everyone's After The Nerd :: WHAT!" Chapter Two.

Thank You.

Kaiyako Kagami

#49 Jan 30th, 2:59am
Mercyette
OFF TOPIC: Sorry if this posts a couple of times. My computer keeps messing up! END OFF-TOPIC

Reviewed second chapter of "Nerd That Everyones After". It's going pretty well!

Please reviewed "Leaning Towards Love" next if you can! Thanks!

#50 Jan 30th, 11:04am


Moderator(s): Fractured Illusion, Imalefty,
Rule(s):
  1. Forums are not to be used to post stories.
  2. All discussions, language and content, must be suitable for teens.
  3. The owner/moderator(s) of this forum is solely responsible for content posted within this area.
  4. All forum abuse must be reported to the moderator(s).
Members:
  1. Forum admin/moderator
  2. Fanatic (on site for more than 2 years)
  3. Fan (on site for more than a year)
  4. Regular (on site for more than 6 months)
  5. Camper (on site for more than a month)
  6. Apprentice (on site for more than a week)
  7. Newbie (on site for less than a week)

All times are GMT -8, US Pacific Time Zone.
Return to Top