Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Fractured Illusion's Forums » The Review Game Topic Subscription

Forums » The Review Game » The Review Game: Stories - Easy Fix
Author Post
Poll
So, did you read the rules before playing The Review Game? And the review requirements in the first post of this topic?
1 Yes
2 No
View Poll Result. Please vote for one of the choices.
Fractured Illusion
Topic: The Review Game: Stories - Easy Fix

This is the place to come if you want reviews for a story, and the review type is "easy fix", aka a simple review.

You can use whichever RG you like: Stories and/or Multi-chap. Just because your story is multi-chap does not mean you cannot use the Story RGs. These RGs are all voluntary.

For Review Game rules and some fun facts, go to "Read this first!".

---

Moving on, this is the basic structure of the Review Game:

Person 1 says: Review "My Lucky Dream"!

Person 2 says: Ok, I reviewed "My Lucky Dream", ch 1 . So can the next person please review "Stereotypes" or "Window"?

Person 3 says: Done (I did "Window", chapter 4), so can the next person review "Stranger"? Thanks.

---

For Stories Easy Fix, your review needs to fulfill these requirements, otherwise you will not be seen as someone who has fulfilled their obligation and you can thus not participate.

REVIEW REQUIREMENTS:

You need to state one thing you liked and *why*, and one thing you didn't like/could be improved, and *why*. Giving more feedback is not prohibited, but giving less than this is. Flaming is also prohibited. Being constructive is not.

If you absolutely can only find good or less good things to say, then please state two things you liked and *why*, or two things you didn't like and *why*. The review will be seen as invalid otherwise.

Restating the same thing does not count as a why. "I really enjoyed the piece because I thought it was very enjoyable" does not count as a why. "I really enjoyed the piece. It was enjoyable because the characters were relateable" does count as a why.

Phrases like "no mistakes" or "good job" do not count as a like. If you cannot find a dislike then write another distinct like do not say "there are no mistakes." That will not count. Saying "good job" or other similar phrases will not count as a like on a piece either. It is not specific.

Here are templates to ensure your review clearly fulfills the qualifications, you can use any of them if you choose, but they are not required:

1) I liked... because... I disliked... because...

2) I liked... because... I liked... because...

3)I disliked... because... I disliked... because...

If you are still unsure on how the review requirement for Easy Fix is viewed, look at this post for guidance.

---

FIRST STORY TO REVIEW:

As this is a continuation of a previous thread, the last participant is the first one up to get a review in here. Eponine254 is next with Geography Lesson (preferred), but other stories are fine too.

LET THE GAMES BEGIN!

#1 Sep 18th, 12:36pm . Edited by Lime-Cat, Sep 18th, 1:37pm
dragonflydreamer

--OFF TOPIC--

Woot! First :D

--END OFF TOPIC--

Reviewed "Geography Lesson" by Eponine254.

Please review Wishing Wall by Point of Reason. Either the oneshot or the multi-chap, your choice.

#2 Sep 18th, 6:25pm . Edited Sep 18th, 6:27pm
Eponine254

Reviewed Wishing Wall chapter6 (according to FP - it's actually chapter 5).

Geography Lesson is preferred, but anything is great for me, thanks! :)

#3 Sep 19th, 1:32am
TreeWhisperer

I reviewed Geography Lesson. Can someone review Revived?

#4 Sep 19th, 7:40am
HannaThing

Reviewed Revived.

Please review Zombie Treehouse Dance Party 3 (joke title!) Warning! Femmslash!

Thanks in advance!

#5 Sep 19th, 7:45am . Edited Sep 19th, 7:48am
Eponine254

Reviewed Zombie Treehouse Dance Party 3 (I love the title!)

Any of mine, please!

#6 Sep 19th, 8:11am
KelaBelle

I've read

Only Fantasy. (very nice) :)

Come someone read my Barbie Gets Kidnapped Story Or My Best Friends A Vampire. ( its getting beta'd)

#7 Sep 19th, 9:22am
Vic Taylor

I reviewed My Best Friend's A Vampire.

Please review chapter 4 of Three Small Dots.

#8 Sep 19th, 11:55am
Eponine254

I reviewed chapter 4 of Three Small Dots.

Please review any of my stories!

#9 Sep 20th, 1:27am
gonnadielafing

Reviewed Eponine254's Geography Lesson (Ch.1)

Please review: Ch.3 of One plus one

#10 Sep 20th, 8:16am
Kristin Teabag

Reviewed Chapter 3 of 'One plus one'

Can someone review 'The Morphine' chapter 3?

#11 Sep 20th, 1:17pm
Chasing Skylines

Reviewed "Morphine," chapter three.

Please review "Shattered Snowflakes," chapter two.

#12 Sep 20th, 2:25pm
Mintiee x

Reviewed shattered snowflakes chapter 2.

Review for Chapter 5 of Do I Laugh Or Cry? Please, :)

-M.

#13 Sep 21st, 7:49am
Eponine254

Reviewed Chapter 5 of Do I Laugh Or Cry?

Any of mine, please!

#14 Sep 22nd, 9:46am
katietheunicorn

Reviewed Not Such a Superhero After All.

Please do Shiver Dog. Thanks!

#15 Sep 22nd, 11:11am
Eponine254

I reviewed Shiver Dog, Chapter 1.

Please review anything of mine!

#16 Sep 22nd, 12:16pm
KelaBelle

Reviewed. Inkstain.

Someone please review , The Nanny Sitters Club. Its been Beta'd.

#17 Sep 22nd, 1:40pm
Fractured Illusion

--- OFF TOPIC ---

@KelaBelle

You need to state two separate (dis)likes and a why to each. Your review lacked a second why. Thus you are not up next this time.

--- END OFF TOPIC ---

Eponine254 is up with any story of theirs

#18 Sep 22nd, 1:43pm
Isca

I reviewed "Inkstains."

Please review any chapter of "A Looking Glass World."

#19 Sep 22nd, 5:39pm
Sloshy McBucket

Reviewed A Looking Glass World

Please somebody do ICouldWriteABetterVampireStoryThanStephenieMeyer. Thanks.

#20 Sep 22nd, 7:39pm
gonnadielafing

Reviewed Ch.1 of ICouldWriteABetterVampireStoryThanStephenieMeyer

Please review: Ch.4 of One plus one Warning: the material in Ch.4 contains discussion about religion. If this is a touchy subject feel free to review a different chapter.

#21 Sep 22nd, 9:50pm
DeeFective

I reviewed chapter 4 of One Plus One.

Can someone please review the last chapter of Ivy & Isabelle.

Thanks.

#22 Sep 23rd, 5:55pm
Eponine254

Reviewed Ivy & Isabelle, Chapter 4.

Anything of mine, please!

#23 Sep 24th, 4:17am
Sakina the Fallen Angel

Reviewed Chapter 1 of Anja: The Story of a Tragedy.

Please review any chapter of Soul Catcher! :)

#24 Sep 24th, 7:12am
Philodice

Reviewed Chapter 1 of soul catcher. Sorry, couldn't find anything bad to say.

I would like a review on Fairy Bad News, any chapter. If you are under 18 not chapter 2 or 14.

#25 Sep 24th, 10:40am
Eponine254

Reveiwed chapter 1 of Fairy Bad News.

Please review any of my stories!

#26 Sep 24th, 12:59pm
Philodice

I reviewed "Only Fantasy".

Please review any single chapter in "Allure of the mask" or "Fairy bad news".

#27 Sep 24th, 3:19pm
Sakina the Fallen Angel

Reviewed Chapter 1 of Fairy Bad News.

Please review any chapter of Soul Catcher!

#28 Sep 24th, 4:54pm
Zombiefied

I reviewed the first chapter of Soul Catcher. Nice work. Could someone please review 'Dark Intentions' or 'Remember Tomorrow?'

#29 Sep 24th, 9:35pm
Starleaf

I've reviewed Dark Intentions.

Someone please do The Dark Side of Incandescence

#30 Sep 27th, 7:34am
The Lucy Program

Reviewed The Dark Side of Incandescence. Chilling and disturbing read; I definitely recommend it! :]]

Please someone review chapter 9 of Mal'ethil :)

#31 Sep 27th, 3:26pm
Angel's Requiem

Reviewed Mal'ethil, it's a great story (:

Eternity's Lie, pleaseee.

#32 Sep 27th, 8:38pm
Nonlinear

Reviewed Eternity's Lie. The concept, if still mysterious, seems interesting.

Please review Slash Story. It's more of a piece that mocks slash than a slash piece itself if that helps. Thanks.

(Reviewed The Lucy Program's Mal'ethil story. Rule 10 issue resolved.)

#33 Sep 27th, 9:14pm . Edited Sep 27th, 10:52pm
The Lucy Program

Reviewed "Slash Story" - very funny! :'D

Someone please review either chapter 9 of "Mal'ethil" or chapter 4 of "Nerd". Thankyouu:]

#34 Sep 27th, 9:28pm
tabiscus

Reviewed Slash Story.

Please review Voodoo Doll.

#35 Sep 27th, 9:29pm
The Lucy Program

--OFF TOPIC--

Aw, crud, Rule 10 Situation. Nonlinear owes me a review for either chapter 9 of "Mal'ethil" or chapter 4 of "Nerd."

--END OFF TOPIC--

Tabiscus is up next with "Voodoo Doll."

#36 Sep 27th, 9:31pm
Zombiefied

I reviewed 'Nerd.' Can someone please review 'Remember Tomorrow?' (Don't be afraid to take your day's anger out on the story! I need some harsh lovin')

#37 Sep 27th, 9:35pm
Zombiefied

--Off Topic --

Oops, never mind that last post. I'm an idiot. Saw your picture, saw your last post where you asked for 'Nerd,' put the two together and... bah, anyway, you got your free review for 'Nerd.' At least something good came out of that.

--End off topic--

Ok, I corrected my mistake and reviewed 'Voodoo Doll.' Can someone please review 'Remember Tomorrow?'

#38 Sep 27th, 9:38pm . Edited Sep 27th, 9:48pm
Angel's Requiem

Reviewed Remember Tomorrow, and wow! It's an excellent read, the imagery is astounding.

Eternity's Lie, please.

#39 Sep 27th, 10:15pm
Vic Taylor

I reviewed Eternity's Lie.

Could someone please review chapter 24 of Three Small Dots?

#40 Sep 28th, 1:10am
Sakina the Fallen Angel

Reviewed chapter 24 of Three Small Dots.

Please review any chapter of Soul Catcher!

#41 Sep 28th, 1:33am
Eponine254

Reveiwed Chapter 5 of Soul Catcher!

Anything of mine, please. :)

#42 Sep 29th, 4:05am
Starleaf

Reviewed Anja: The Story of a Tragedy.

Someone please review Home's Much Safer. :]

#43 Sep 29th, 5:36am
Sakina the Fallen Angel

Reviewed Home's Much Safer.

Please review any chapter of Soul Catcher.

#44 Sep 29th, 7:36am
gonnadielafing

Reviewed Ch. 21 of Soul Catcher

Please review: Ch. 5 of One plus one.

I've edited this chapter so that the paragraphs are more broken up. Hopefully it will be an easier read.

#45 Sep 29th, 8:36am
simpleplan13

--OFF TOPIC--

Backing up... Zombiefied your review off The Lucy Program was valid. Therefore, they do owe you a review. It is simply a rule 10 withing a rule 10.

--END OFF TOPIC--

gonnadielafing is up next with One Plus One (CH 5)

#46 Sep 29th, 9:42am . Edited Sep 29th, 9:43am
rmzucker

reviewed chapter ch. 5 of one plus one

by the way it is very unique and amazingly thoughtful

please review Flick chapter 5

#47 Sep 29th, 6:13pm
E.S. Lundgren

Reviewed Chapter Five of Flick

Please review for Chapter Three of Vampire and The Romantics! Thank you!

#48 Sep 30th, 8:16pm . Edited Sep 30th, 8:33pm
Eponine254

Reviewed Chapter 3 of Vampire and The Romantics.

Anything of mine, please!

#49 Oct 01st, 7:36am
rmzucker

reviewed 93 steps

please review either Flick or Fire

#50 Oct 01st, 8:08am


Moderator(s): Fractured Illusion, Lime-Cat, simpleplan13, Imalefty,
Rule(s):
  1. Forums are not to be used to post stories.
  2. All discussions including language and content must be suitable for teens.
  3. The owner/moderator(s) of this forum is solely responsible for content posted within this area.
  4. All forum abuse must be reported to the moderator(s).
Members:
  1. Forum admin/moderator
  2. Fanatic (on site for more than 2 years)
  3. Fan (on site for more than a year)
  4. Regular (on site for more than 6 months)
  5. Camper (on site for more than a month)
  6. Apprentice (on site for more than a week)
  7. Newbie (on site for less than a week)

All times are GMT -8, US Pacific Time Zone.
Return to Top