Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Fractured Illusion's Forums » The Review Game Topic Subscription

Forums » The Review Game » The Review Game: Multi-Chap - Depth
Author Post
Poll
So, did you read the rules before playing The Review Game? And the review requirements in the first post of this topic?
1 Yes
2 No
View Poll Result. Please vote for one of the choices.
Stargirl Lilac

-- Off Topic --

Last four chapters of Rainbow Shackles please!

Confetti Kitty the last two chapters that you requested (chapters 8 and 9) are over 4000 words in length. Therefore, as according to the rules your max request of chapters can only be 3.

-- End Off Topic --

Confetti Kitty is next with 3 chapters of "Rainbow Shackles"

#201 Jul 20th, 1:09pm . Edited by Lime-Cat, Jul 20th, 1:20pm
Confetti Kitty

-Off Topic- Okay, sorry. -End off topic-

Last three chapters of Rainbow Shackles then.

#202 Jul 20th, 2:04pm
DeeFective

EDIT: Reviewed the last three chapters of Rainbow Shackles.

Can someone please review two chapters of Ivy & Isabelle.

#203 Jul 20th, 9:35pm . Edited Jul 20th, 10:05pm
Kit-Kat Punk-lover

Going to reveiw Ivy & Isabelle :D

Edit: Reviewed two chapters of Ivy and Isabelle. Someone please review two chapters of Twisted Smiles :)

#204 Jul 20th, 10:49pm . Edited Jul 20th, 11:09pm
Faithless Juliet

I review two chapters of Twisted Smiles, could someone review two chapters of Allegory please. Thank you.

#205 Jul 21st, 11:04am
The Eternal Masquerade

Reviewing "Allegory" :)

#206 Jul 21st, 11:19am
Lime-Cat

-- OFF TOPIC --

Kit-Kat Punk-Lover: Your to chapter 3 of DeeFective's "Ivy & Isabelle" did not meet depth requirements. Remember: any comments along the lines of "no mistakes" for grammar does not count. Therefore, you only have 3 categories. Of those 3 categories, the one for Ending was very marginal - essentially, you said the same thing using different words. Be careful in the future. Thanks.

-- END OFF TOPIC --

Faithless Juliet is next with 2 chapters of "Allegory"

EDIT:

The Eternal Masquerade is reviewing "Allegory". Please make a new post when you have finished reviewing as you cannot edit my post. Thanks.

#207 Jul 21st, 11:21am . Edited Jul 21st, 11:22am
The Eternal Masquerade

Reviewed two chapters of Allegory... Two of Vieovita please :) Preferably the last two, but whatever works! ♥

#208 Jul 21st, 12:22pm
Lea Ai

Reviewing "Vieovita".

EDIT: Reviewed all four chapters of "Vieovita".

Please review four chapters of "Sovereign"...I prefer something after chapter 6, but anything is fine :-D. Thanks!

#209 Jul 21st, 12:28pm . Edited Jul 23rd, 9:37am
Kit-Kat Punk-lover

Reviewing Sovereign :D

Edit: Reviewed four chapters of Sovereign and liked it alot :D

Could someone please review four chapters of Twisted Smiles please? Thanks!

#210 Jul 27th, 8:12pm . Edited Jul 27th, 8:42pm
Palm Tree

Reviewing Twisted Smiles. 8D

Edit:: Reviewed all four chapters of Twisted Smiles. Update soon, KK!

And, because my first three chapters are all over 4,000 words, I request that only the first two of Eden, the bare minimum, be read and reviewed. Please and thank you! :3

#211 Jul 27th, 8:48pm . Edited Jul 28th, 10:58am
DeeFective

Never mind, I'm reviewing Eden. I promise it'll be done before the end of today.

#212 Jul 30th, 11:45am . Edited Aug 03rd, 9:24am
DeeFective

I reviewed three chapters of Eden.

Can someone please review the last three chapters of Ivy & Isabelle.

Thanks.

#213 Aug 03rd, 11:37am
dragonflydreamer

Reviewing "Ivy & Isabelle."

EDIT: Reviewed all four chapters of "Ivy & Isabelle." Highly recommended.

Please review three chapters of Defenseless, We Will Stand by Avant-garde and Dream Realms.

#214 Aug 05th, 4:15am . Edited Aug 06th, 9:37pm
MikiSweety

Reviewing Defenseless, We Will Stand.

EDIT: Reviewed 3 chapters of Defenseless, We Will Stand. Please review 3 chapters of A Phoenix's Rise (you can skip the prologue if you'd like. It's short and not really needed).

#215 Aug 07th, 6:37am . Edited Aug 09th, 8:55am
Searon

Reading At Phoenix's Rise.

Edit: Finished. Reviewed Chapters 1-3, and read the prelude, but found too short to comment. Started slow, but getting good ^_^.

If someone could read my story: The Chronicles of Starlyn: The Fear of Magic . Prelude + Chapters 1-3, I'd appreciate it, if the word amount are past the rules, as much as you can read. Thank you, and it's fun to finally begin the review game.

#216 Aug 09th, 11:16am . Edited Aug 09th, 5:13pm
Chasing Skylines

-- Off Topic --

I'm sorry, but your reviews do not count.

If you have any problems with the ruling, please go to Problems/Questions.

-- End Off Topic --

MikiSweety is up next with chapters 1-3 of A Phoenix's Rise.

#217 Aug 10th, 10:53am
Searon

*Off Topic*

I'm sorry my reviews didn't impress you. Just to clear things up, I have read the rules before even participating in these review events. I didn't realize it had to be exact on how many sentences of each thing and how many it was. I implied a few variations of some of what you want to be put in. When I browsed some of the ones done in the past, not everyone put as much detail as you guys require and get away with it, So I wasn't too stressed on copying the exact format when I just reviewed and let know what I thought of the story. MikiSweety wished for any 3 chapters of his story to be reviewed. I reviewed 1-3 under the wrong format. I will now read chapter 4-5 of his in your terms. I apoligize for the misunderstanding.

*End Off Topic*

#218 Aug 10th, 6:44pm
Lime-Cat

-- OFF TOPIC --

Sabotuer: As SeasideDreams already said, if you have a problem with the ruling, you should be bringing it up in the Problems/Questions thread. I have said in the Stories Depth thread that if you have a problem with the review standards, you are more than welcome to bring a way to improve them in the Suggestions thread. That said, I still do not appreciate the attitude you are playing this game with. Your review of chapter 4 did not count because as far as I can tell, you only commented on 1 category - opening. Your comment on grammar did not count because we have a rule that states anything along the lines of "no mistakes" for the grammar section do not count.

I would highly suggest you try out the Easy Fix threads before venturing into the Depth threads as I feel you can expect a higher success rate there. As a final note, always state who is next when making an off-topic post to avoid confusion.

-- END OFF TOPIC --

MikiSweety is next with chapters 1-3 of "A Phoenix's Rise"

#219 Aug 10th, 8:00pm
Searon

*Off Topic*

First off, I posted a topic already, don't know if it didn't post due to the fictionpress error, or if it got deleted. Now that the fictionpress error is gone however you can see the reviews I was talking about. I reviewed chapter 5-6 of A Phoenix Rise as an apoligy right after being told my reviews weren't good enough. I already said I don't have a problem with the reviewing which is why I made up for it by reviewing the next two chapters under the right conditions. It's my way of saying I'm sorry, and it won't happen again. Chapter 4 review you speak of was part of my first 3 reviews, and I already know that it didn't have enough. Again, I'm sorry to everyone in the game, and when I review the next person I shall not fail at the qualifications.

*END off topic*

MikiSweety is next with 3 chapters of "A Phoenix's Rise"

#220 Aug 12th, 7:55am
The Lucy Program

Currently reviewing "A Phoenix's Rise."

Edit: Reviewed 3 chapters of "A Phoenix's Rise."

Could someone please review 3 chapers of "Mal'ethil"? Thankyou:]

#221 Aug 14th, 4:08pm . Edited Aug 16th, 2:27pm
katietheunicorn

Currently reviewing three chapters of "Mal'ethil."

Edit: Complete. Please review 6 chapters of "Trails to the Outside." I realize I may be overasking, so if wanted the prologue is short so you may skip and just do 2-6, technically reviewing 5 chapters. :P Thanks!

Double Edit: I have noticed my mistake in chapter three where I said "I" instead of Brenna. I'm begging you, don't kill me about it. :P I admit I'm one for uploading without looking back so I need to stop doing that. ^^; Otherwise, please, please criticize. I need a little rough in my life.

#222 Aug 17th, 8:48am . Edited Aug 17th, 10:42am
mikey magee

--Off Topic--

Katie, you only reviewed 3 chapters of Mal'ethil. According to the rules you can only ask for what you have given. Meaning you can't ask for 6 reviews when you yourself have only give three. So you can only ask for three (3) reviews since you gave that many

--On Topic--

katietheunicorn is up with 3 chapters of "Trails to the Outside"

EDITED on August 20th 1:36 am, I am reviweing "Trials to the outside"

Reviewed 6 of "Trials to the outside"

Please review 6 of "Fireflies sleep in the Grass"

#223 Aug 18th, 9:30am . Edited Aug 20th, 1:04am
vinny2

Reviewing six chapter of Fireflies Sleep in the Grass.

Fished my reviews of Fireflies Sleep in the Grass.

Six chapters of The Powerpuff Girls, please! Thanks in advance!

#224 Sep 02nd, 6:53pm . Edited Sep 02nd, 8:22pm
idraax

Am currently reading it. Will get back to you with a review.

#225 Sep 06th, 1:19pm
Lime-Cat

-- OFF TOPIC --

idraax has well exceeded the time limit for reviewing mikey magee and they did not edit their placeholder post nor did they submit any reviews. Therefore, mikey's story, "The Powerpuff Girls" is still up for review.

-- END OFF TOPIC --

mikey magee is next with 6 chapters of "The Powerpuff Girls"

#226 Sep 13th, 9:29pm
MikiSweety

Reviewing the Powerpuff Girls

Edit: Reviewed 6 chapters of the Powerpuff Girls. Please review 6 chapters of "A Phoenix's Rise". Later chapters preferred (but there are only really 7 chapters, so...)

#227 Sep 18th, 5:25pm . Edited Sep 20th, 12:14pm
Stargirl Lilac

Reviewing A Phoenix's Rise.

Edit: Please review 6 consecutive chapters of Disconsolate. Thank you.

#228 Sep 27th, 11:54am . Edited Sep 29th, 12:06pm
sugaplumprincess

Reviewing 'Disconsolate'

Edit: Finished reviewing 6 chapters of 'Disconsolate'

3 chapters of 'The Opal Fox' please, later chapters preferred

#229 Sep 30th, 9:20am . Edited Oct 03rd, 7:39pm
E.S. Lundgren

Reviewed three chapters of The Opal Fox

Reviews for three chapters of Vampire and The Romantics would be much appreciated!

#230 Nov 02nd, 1:54pm . Edited Nov 02nd, 5:10pm


Moderator(s): Fractured Illusion, Lime-Cat, simpleplan13, Imalefty,
Rule(s):
  1. Forums are not to be used to post stories.
  2. All discussions including language and content must be suitable for teens.
  3. The owner/moderator(s) of this forum is solely responsible for content posted within this area.
  4. All forum abuse must be reported to the moderator(s).
Members:
  1. Forum admin/moderator
  2. Fanatic (on site for more than 2 years)
  3. Fan (on site for more than a year)
  4. Regular (on site for more than 6 months)
  5. Camper (on site for more than a month)
  6. Apprentice (on site for more than a week)
  7. Newbie (on site for less than a week)

All times are GMT -8, US Pacific Time Zone.
Return to Top