Amazing and definitely one of the best stories here on FanFiction. I loved every bit of it and enjoyed it to bits! The drama, romance, and humor were absolutely perfect. Thank you so much for sharing this amazing story with us! :)

really beautiful

This is a truly awesome story. I do love it.
The characters are fantastic, really likeable, and I love that Janie isn't weak, she's pretty ballsy. Hope all works out for Jhonny and Natalie because they are adorable, been rooting for them since the beginning like a crazy person.
Great story, I will definitely re-read this a billion times:)

Wait... did she ever read the diary? If not, what was in it?

I loved this story!

She forgave him way too easily I would have been pissed if someone read my diary laughing about or talked about it or wouldn't give it back and gets mad and accuses me of not trying hard enough on an application and breaks up with me. Yeah what she did is nowhere near what he did. Other than that I liked it. Great story. :)

Aww, right in the feels. So perfect

This was amazing. One of the best that I've read. I don't know why there aren't more review fawning of this story!?

Pure awesomeness. The chemistry between the main characters was amazing. Plus I love ny. I want to live there someday but taxes are too high so unless I'm some rich millionaire, I'll prob stick to a state with low tax rates.

I really enjoyed this story. I believe it's good enough to be published although you would need to majorly edit it, fix some minor punctuation and grammar problems but then you would deprive people on ficpress to read it for free so maybe not haha. I like your sense of humor and the plot flowed so smoothly that iu had me hooked from the very beginning to the very end. I also liked the chemistry between the two main characters. Nicely written :))))

This fanfiction is amazing! Honestly, I don't ever review but I felt like your story was too good to not review. It has the perfect combination of emotional and humorous moments. I like how Janie isn't annoying and stubborn like many main characters who were humiliated in high school. I love her personality and her chemistry with Mike! Also, the story line and the development of the story was very realistic. Good job!

Absolutely amazing! I love how everything turned out and i would definitely like to read a sequel, although the epilogue is perfect anyway. Well that was such an awesome job so keep it up! I look forward to reading more of your stories :D xx

...Gavin isn't even a factor in the story. He's definitely not her love interest. Boo. You made it seem as if it was going to be a love triangle or something. Sucha disappointment. :(

AHHHHHH! This story is just too cute. I love hearing about the two of their cute childhood pasts. Young Natalie and Jhonny are seriously so cute. They are adorable. I never experienced baby-sitting, I wasn't like them as a kid. I like how Mike was with her in those baby-sitting times. Their nicknames are what I see as so endearing. Creamy is so freakin' hilarious with his awesome personality. I still don't understand what his names means. I thought what he had written in the diary was so cute. I can believe why he kept it. I can't believe how he was so committed to her while he was in NYU. I can't believe he saved a room for her and tried so hard to get into that school. I am glad they finally sorted themselves out. Lala really changed, it is so good to see that. It shows that people can surely grow up! I am so so happy to see such a happy ending. I think that the two are so amazing. I really do envy their relationship. It is unbelievable though how she has only been with him. That is so amazing. Thank you for writing this awesome awesome story.

I love the title of this story! It was adorable, just like the story itself. In the beginning the grammatical errors were pretty distracting, but it got much better towards the end. I wish there more scenes with Mike and Janie not fighting/hiding behind their pride. But those bickering scenes really did make for a funny story.

This was beautifull

The content and the spelling and the grammer were all top notch...

Good Job :)