Reviews for Reason and Romance Redux
swimchickslam chapter 1 . 1/13/2007
Whoah this is really different :P But really good too! I hope you continue with it :D
K.B. Hanna chapter 1 . 1/13/2007
I do believe we have a winner with this revision. Adrian has a bit of spunk that seemed to be missing from the previous version. It'd be interesting if she was a bit of a hellion, but I don't think that's quite in her personality.

It's nice to know she doesn't like Karen all that much in this version. Usually hostility does result in situations such as this.

The change of scenery was refreshing. Adrian's now in Alex's position, only it was summer in the previous version, wasn't it?

Jason's not a filthy scumbag in this one. It's different, but there wouldn't much Adrian could do in Arizona about it, unless she finds out some sleasy escapades in the future. I don't think it would be necessary though.

I'm not sure what else to add seeing as my brain just completely turned off. Anyway, good luck with the new edition. So far, it's proving to be stronger just as you said.
Lena Niccolas chapter 1 . 1/13/2007
I like it, I love the first one, but this is great too. I think I'll be just as satisfied, as long as the ending is happy ;)
Blue Devil012 chapter 1 . 1/13/2007
Wow, a complete switch and reserve of situations for the original. :D I like it, wonder whats gonna happen when the girls are living in the Montgomery's house.
JustLikeMe91 chapter 1 . 1/13/2007
This is so exciting!

I loved the old version, and I think it's majordomo cool that you're making a entire new story! I can't wait for more!
jess chapter 1 . 1/13/2007
I am thrilled you are doing a re-write on this story! I loved Reason and Romance, but you seem to be taking its development in a different direction. Thanks for sharing the new version!
DinaY chapter 1 . 1/13/2007
i like this one, i think this one is goin to be much better then the other one, not that the other sucks, cuz it doesnt! its really good, except i like this start better.. im rambling arent i? hmm... well i hope u update it soon
lovely-lips chapter 1 . 1/13/2007
I think your changes might be a little too significant. It doesn't even sound the same-it almost sounds less..."something". I don't know maybe it's just me, but I thought the first one was great and I DO believe in revisions. I'm revising a story on another sight, but I don't know if that means you should CHANGE the way the whole story went about- but it is YOUR story, so I won’t “dislike” it for NO reason. I just have to say- I hope this one makes you happy. I'll be happy with the first one any time, but I’ll continue to read this one as long as you keep updating it. Almost like {comparing and contrasting}?
emptyword chapter 1 . 1/13/2007
Interesting, Myrika! I remember you mentioned something about a revision in your bio, but a different setting, different characters? I hadn't expected a total rewrite, I admit. Not that I'm complaining. This looks as promising as the original if not more so. :) So fraught with possibilities... I look forward to following this one too.
My Silence chapter 1 . 1/13/2007
I really like this version so far. I think it's interesting that you've decided to have Adrian's family move to the Montgomery's state instead of the other way around. This should be more interesting. Adrian seems a lot stronger and more equipped with comebacks. I really like that change. I'm excited to see the new version because this is one of my favorite stories on here!
kazahana chapter 1 . 1/13/2007
I was really surprised receive the email notification of the 1st chapter. I read it straight away and loved it! I like how you moved the Blakes instead of the Montgomerys and how it's no longer set in summer so we'll get to read about the children's interactions in school. That should be fun!
snow blossoms chapter 1 . 1/13/2007
"I do hope that some of you guys will come to appreciate this new version"? Dude, when can we not appreciate what you write? Seriously, you're a freaking awesome writer. Anyway, back to the chapter, I like the new spin on R&R. Both of them are younger and in high school, which means that sex is going to be a more hellish manner, right? Also, Adrian crying? She has emotions right in the first chapter? Wow, that's a major (but very interesting) change from the first one. Thanks for updating and I can't wait to see the next chappie! G'luck on all your school projects and whatnot!
sleepiedreamer chapter 1 . 1/13/2007
im glad your keeping the old one...its nice to read a different one too...and wow i would hate to be in her shoes...not only do you have it up there but also next door! life sucks over there...im surprised she handt made an public outburst yet..lol i would have been and i see the changes in character...i hope you kept most of alex's friends they were pretty cool lol cant wait to read more...update more soon looking forward to it xD
Ms.Romantic chapter 1 . 1/13/2007
yayy.

i;m excitedd
hopelessromantic444 chapter 1 . 1/13/2007
OH LOVING IT SO FAR! I LOVED YOUR LAST FIC AND I'M SURE THIS ONE WILL BE JUST AS GOOD IF NOT BETTER D
4,312 | « Prev Page 1 .. 276 283 284 285 286 287 .. Last Next »