|Reviews for Musings on the One Ring & the Invisibility Cloak|
| forgot my password chapter 1 . 5/14/2011
Good point, but I must disagree that they're the same thing. The Ring does not make one "invisible" only; rather, it thrusts the person into an alternative dimension in which he is visible to the Dark Lord Sauron, and the Dark Lord's workings are visible to him as well. He is invisible to the world, but given to the "other world" as long as he's wearing it. There is a lot more complexity to the Ring than the invisibility cloak.
I say this as an LOTR fan, but I don't know much about Harry Potter, so sorry if I'm wrong. Cool thoughts, though!
| ncbx chapter 1 . 5/12/2011
I can see what you are getting at. Very interesting. Yes, very interesting indeed. I like it. I've never really though about it, but you make a good point.