Ripped my twisted heart in half,

One to you, one to him.

Can't decide which one's the right one.

One of you gave me my heart back,

You didn't want it.

Don't think that'll stop me,

I'm gunna give it back to you.

The other can't see that I'm giving it to him;

He's just handing me his,

And I'm not sure if I want it.

I'm about to take it,

But do I really want his half to make my twisted heart whole?

I want them both,

But a girl always wants what she can't have just an itty bit more.