Verse One:
I can't believe my eyes
I wish I wouldn't
Because to my surprise:
She's wearing your shirt
Your buttoning your pants
She's misplaced he skirt
How could you take the chance?

Chorus:
Why couldn't you love me?

What didn't you see?
Why couldn't you love me?
What didn't you seeeeeee?
Oh I loved you for sure
If you couldn't love me…
How could you love her?

Verse Two:
What I saw that night
Wish I'd never seen
Because she was right:
You'd be with her
She'd get in your pants
Everything we were
How could you take the chance?

Chorus:
Why couldn't you love me?
What didn't you see?
Why couldn't you love me?
What didn't you seeeeeee?
Oh I loved you for sure
If you couldn't love me…
How could you love her?

Verse Three:
I won't ask "why?"
Because I've known you too long
And I know you'll lie:
And you won't even look me
Straight in the eye
Because you'll think
That I know it's a lie…
I know it's a lie…

Written by: Annamarie Claire