The Review Game
News: We have a new For Fun thread called Chain Story! Go crazy with it.
New Follow Forum Follow Topic
« Prev Page 1 .. 32 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 52 .. Last Next »
Kyllorac

We could have it both for genres they write in as well as the genres they participate with. The format could look like

Name - Genres requested most often - Other genres they write in

or something along those lines.

It might be nice to also include genres they prefer to read/review, but I don't think that's necessary, and it may be too much info. XD I do think that including genres they will not review is important, though.

6/19/2008 . Edited 6/19/2008 #1,231
Imalefty

i'm not exactly sure what the sug is... O.o uh... i guess i've been away too long.

but the list of active members and genres they write in would be good... just for reference. maybe put their nicks in there, too, so that newbies don't get confused. XD

are we thinking of separating RGs into genres...? i don't really get the other sug...

but if it IS separating RGs into genres... we already had this discussion (way back when the forum was first created) and... well... we didn't exactly think it would work all that well.

-Lefty

6/19/2008 #1,232
Kyllorac

@Lefty - We have all agreed (for the most part) that having genre-based RGs is a bad idea.

Adding nicknames to the list would be a really good idea. n_n Especially since some of us have such strange ones. XD

6/19/2008 #1,233
Fractured Illusion

Post nr 1215 and the discussion around that one, Lefty D: Not the RG genre, that we won't do, no worries.

@Kylie

I like that format!

Shall we start? Perhaps divide into areas of responsibilities? (ie someone takes Stories EF last four pages, someone does Depth, someone does both Multi ??)

6/19/2008 #1,234
Kyllorac

So revised format:

Name (nicknames) - Genres most often asked for - Other genres write in - Genres will not read

6/19/2008 #1,235
Fractured Illusion

No. Not what they want to read! That's pointless. Everyone chooses who to review, either way! Lets skip it. Otherwise I think that is a good formula.

Now, for area dividing?

6/19/2008 #1,236
Kyllorac

Mkay. No genres they don't read.

I have to go to class right now, but I think I can manage to do the last 4 pages of Stories EF later today.

6/19/2008 . Edited 6/19/2008 #1,237
Imalefty

agh okay... here we go...

i think it's a good idea. and i don't think that it should deter people from leaving good criticism... since reviews are public anyway. i don't think, though, that depth should include a like and a dislike... i think depth is really to just go in depth. if there IS something that a reviewer likes, he/she can go into it in depth. but if there isn't... then... there isn't. O.o

and this would help make the RG flow smoother... so that people can tell if someone qualifies or not. :)

-Lefty

6/19/2008 #1,238
simpleplan13

I get not wanting to put the list in the RG, but what about a link to the list for ppl who only do the RG & dont go to OT ot suggestions or whatnot.

6/19/2008 #1,239
Fractured Illusion

@Lefty

Which of 0,1 and 2 are you refering to?

@Genre

Stories EF last four pages - Kylie

Stories Depth last four pages - Frac (done)

Stories Multi - Mini (done)

Stories EF - four pages before the last four pages -

Someone, volunteer!

Then make a list of the participants according to this formula:

Name (nicknames) - Genres the author most often asked for - Other genres write in

Ie;

Imalefty (Lefty) - General - Fantasy

6/19/2008 . Edited 6/19/2008 #1,240
simpleplan13

I volunteer for which ever you want.

6/19/2008 #1,241
Fractured Illusion

Then please do Multi! :D There's 4 pages total so you're not getting more or less

6/19/2008 #1,242
simpleplan13

Fine with me. I'll do it after lunch. Do I post it here or PM you? Also, waht about my link suggestion?

6/19/2008 #1,243
Imalefty

O_o? uh what? XD

i was referring to your response to meve's sug. i think.

-Lefty

6/19/2008 #1,244
Fractured Illusion

I am still not sure about the link one. I don't know why people need to know of this in the RG, I see absolutely no use for it. When someone is up, they naturally check the story and see what kind it is before they start reviewing (IF genres matter to them. If genres dont matter they maybe wont bother to check)

This list was not created for RG. It is to see what kind of genres RG players deal with mostly. Trivia, I guess.

And post it here. No pm

@Lefty

If you dont know about Sug 0, Sug 1, or Sug 2 then you did it wrong! T_T

6/19/2008 #1,245
Imalefty

oh aha.

okay so...

@ 0 - YES! please let the person actually NAME the poem he/she reviewed.

@ 1 + 2 - have them also post the review they just gave so that the next player can see if it qualifies or not... and makes it easier to mod.

*sigh* if i still did it wrong, i'm not trying again. XD

-Lefty

6/19/2008 #1,246
simpleplan13

Not that the ppl who play the RG need to know. But they might be interested in knowing the statistics. Especially someone might want to know before they play if ppl as for a lot of fantasy reviews because they love fantasy I just thought ppl who ply the RG would enjoy this knowledge even if they dont do OT of make suggestions.

6/19/2008 #1,247
Fractured Illusion

Update:

Sug 0 has been implemented and is mandatory.

6/19/2008 #1,248
simpleplan13

Multi-Cap Depth

Esther Jade (Heda)- Fantasy- General

Imalefty (Lefty)- Fantasy, Young Adult- General, Romance

Kaiyako Kagami- Manga

l. fayette- Fantasy- Historical

Arianna Sterling (Era)- Fantasy- Horror, Romance, Supernatural

Kyllorac (Kylie)- General- Mythology, Supernatural, Horror, Fantasy, Historical, Fable, Historical, Humor, Nauture

Deimus Maxiran- Sci-fi- Mystery, Fantasy

B.J. Winters (B.J.)- Mystery- Thriller

rassoodock (rassie)- Romance

KnittingKneedle (Ting Ting or TT)- Young Adult- Romance

adnapusa- Romance- Thriller, Biography, Fantasy

Narc (Narc)- Fantasy- Supernatural

Harmonic Discord (Discy)- Fantasy- Mythology, Sci-fi

Robbertomo Jerome Straightpen (Geronimo)- Supernatural- General, Humor

Multi-chap EF (maybe you wanted them combined, but just in case)

Otseis Ragnarok (Onar)- Action- Supernatural, General, Fantasy, Life, Horror

Kelsci J. Sceasel- Young Adult

KnittingKneedle (Ting Ting or TT)- Young Adult- Romance

Kaiyako Kagami- Manga

Imalefty (Lefty)- Fantasy, Young Adult- General, Romance

l. fayette- Historical, Fantasy

Fiorenza- Fantasy- General

Esther Jade (Heda)- Fantasy- General

Damius- Fantasy

Kyllorac (Kylie)- General- Mythology, Supernatural, Horror, Fantasy, Historical, Fable, Historical, Humor, Nauture

loves him- Romance

Dexterity (Dex)- Fantasy- General, Romance

Oracle of Destiny- Essay, Romance- Young Adult, Humor

thefilmchick- Fantasy

KimHua- Sci-fi- Action, Spiritual, General, Supernatural

Yellers- Romance

Sexy vampirechick- Romance- General

artificial destiny (Art)- Romance

Equilibrium- Fantasy

Narc (Narc)- Fantasy- Supernatural

Harmonic Discord (Discy)- Fantasy- Mythology, Sci-fi

Mercyette (Mercy)- Romance- Spiritual, Fantasy

Teffie (Teflon)- Fantasy

Jesusfreak43091 (Susie)- Romance- Kids, Fantasy, General, Spiritual

I wasn't including essays 'cause I didnt think you could put them as stories, but apparently you can. Do you want me to go back and see who writes essays as other genres?

Should I also go and add poetry as a genre to author's who write poetry as well?

Also, I did all other genre? Should I change it to only genres of other multi-chap stories?

Frac, just double check my nicknames again... I copied some of them from yours, but there are still other's I wasnt sure about.

6/19/2008 . Edited 6/19/2008 #1,249
Fractured Illusion

Overview over Stories Depth.

Name (nicknames) - Genres the author most often asked for - Other genres they write in

---

- Deimus Maxiran - Sci-fi - Mystery, Fantasy

- Evera19 - Horror

- Justin A Caynon - General, Supernatural - Action, Romance

- Ogden-of-the-Moon-Clan - Romance, Supernatural

- Esther Jade (Heda) - Fantasy - General

- Sark - General, Action

- Jesse the Storyteller (Ace) - Fantasy, Horror, Mythology - Young Adult, Spiritual, Romance, Essay, Humor, Supernatural, General, Sci-fi, Kids

- Dowie - Fable - Thriller, Sci-fi

- KnittingKneedle (Ting Tong) - Young Adult, Romance

- starleaf (leafy) - Romance - Horror, Fantasy

- peaceinafrica - Fantasy - Humor

- N.J Robinson - General

- Imalefty (Lefty) - Young Adult - General, Fantasy, Romance, Humor

- B.J. Winters - Mystery - Thriller

- sugaplumprincess (Dr Slump) - Fantasy - Essay

- Harmonic Discord (Discy) - Fantasy - Mythology, Sci-fi

- poorkeitaro - Fantasy

- Asherah Seirei - Fantasy, Manga

- Equilibrium - Fantasy

- OceanLeviathan - Sci-fi - Fantasy

- Audy - Romance - Essay

- Arianna Sterling (Era) - Fantasy, Horror - Romance, Supernatural

- Kyllorac (Kylie) - General, Horror, Historical - Mythology, Humor

- artificial destiny (Art) - Romance

- Dexterity (Dex) - Fantasy - Romance, General

- Sercus Kaynine (Sir) - Fantasy, Historical, General

- Alexandra Jacobson - General - Young Adult

- Eyelyo - Action

- Mercyette (Mercy) - Romance, Spiritual - Fantasy

- xXRecontre-DestineeXx - Romance, General - Essay, Action

- Drallimer - Romance, Young Adult

- Distilledfx (Ant) - Horror - Fantasy

- soojinyeh - Sci-fi - Essay, Humor, General

- Kinderwhore - General, Romance

- Narc - Fantasy - Essay, Supernatural

- Josh Howatt - General

- Lorki - Fantasy - Essay

- Lew Sylva - Historical - General

- exit signs - General - Young Adult

- Anastasia Ambrose - General

- Jesusfreak43091 (Susie) - Horror, Young Adult - Humor, Kids

- Tsubasa Rose - General

- Colorize - Romance

- Erocdrah - Sci-fi - General

- Limited Edition - Romance - Mystery, Young Adult, General, Biography, Essay

- groovi-gal-numba1 - Young Adult

- AlexSanguine (Sanguine) - Fantasy, Horror

- Offering the fire - General

- Sally Can Wait - Romance

- Brian77 - Fantasy

- MaDMaS22 - Sci-fi - Fantasy, Essay

---

When I made this list, I collected:

- Everyone that played on those 4 pages, even if they only did one time

- The genres they requested even if they only did one time, I still counted in for "most often asked for" since it's too bothersome otherwise

- I only looked at the first mentioned genres for Jesusfreak since she have so many stories and it is hard to tell what is a story and what is a poem since they're all around the same word count.

@Mini

No there is no need to mention poems, since we only focus on story genres anyway.

Also, Robbertomo Jerome Straightpen, is called Geronimo

6/19/2008 . Edited 6/19/2008 #1,250
simpleplan13

Thanks.. Ill add that nickname. You do know most of Jesusfreak's things especially in the beginning are poetry, not stories, right?

Would you like me to do another section?

6/19/2008 . Edited 6/19/2008 #1,251
Fractured Illusion

No other section is needed. Kylie got the last one, really.

@Sug 1 and 2

Me and Mini oppose it/voice skepticism

Meve and Lefty are pro.

I think we need to discuss this more.

6/19/2008 #1,252
Kyllorac

Stories EF: Pages 19-22

AlexSanguine (Sanguine) - Fantasy, Horror

Sexy vampirechick - Romance - General, Mystery, Humor, Thriller

Dot Cubed - Romance

SympleSymon (Cy, Cyclops) - Young Adult - Thriller, Manga, Humor

Katenheimer - no preference - Romance, Humor, Essay

Distilledfx - Horror - Fantasy

Jesusfreak43091 - no preference - Young Adult, Humor, Mythology, Kids, Romance, Fantasy, General, Spiritual

artificial destiny - Romance

Hammer83 - Action

dragonflydreamer (Sparkles) - Fantasy

Chewyy the Moofin - Romance

Asherah Seirei - Fantasy - Manga

N.J Robinson (Frogger) - General

Anastasia Ambrose - General

alittlebitconfused (Beta) - Romance

Erocdrah - Sci-Fi - General

Teffie (Tefflon) - Fantasy

Josh Howatt - General

Colorize - Romance

A-Q-K - Supernatural, Thriller - School, Sci-Fi, Mystery, Play, Horror

groovi-gal-numba1 - Young Adult

Harmonic Discord - Fantasy - Mythology, Sci-Fi

Silver Dollar - Romance - Humor

dreamer999 - Supernatural - General, Horror *native language Spanish

Limited Edition - Romance - Mystery, Young Adult, General, Biography, Fantasy, Horror *seems to write in Swedish as well (though I'm not sure)

Mahone-chic-89 - Romance, Action - Biography

Stargirl Lilac - Romance - Humor

Lachrymosa - Romance - Fantasy, Horror, Supernatural, Sci-Fi, Action

Equilibrium - Fantasy

EliXir15 - Fantasy

Lady Blood - Young Adult - Thriller

soojinyeh - Sci-Fi - Humor, General

Keshuoo - Romance

asylum writer (Aussie?) - Humor - Action

Dexterity (Dex) - Fantasy - General, Romance

Aasia - Fantasy

eamane tinuviel - no preference - Humor, Supernatural, Mythology

Drallimer - Romance - Young Adult

Sally Can Wait - Romance

Trmpetplaya1 - Romance - General, Fantasy

AtlantisGirl12 - General - Fable, Historical, Humor

Amertie - General

When I made this list, I collected:

- Everyone that played on those 4 pages, even if they only did one time

- The genres they requested even if they only did one time, I still counted in for "most often asked for" since it's too bothersome otherwise

- I only looked at the first mentioned genres.

Thank whatever deity you the reader worship that it's over! @_@

6/19/2008 . Edited 6/19/2008 #1,253
Fractured Illusion

Okay, good. Although, for Sanguine, you ARE aware Religion is a POEM genre, right? Not for stories? Ah well, I'll edit it out And this again:

Edit: also I will totally edit out all your (??) because they're really annoying me.

@Sug 1 and 2

Me and Mini oppose it/voice skepticism

Meve and Lefty are pro.

I think we need to discuss this more.

6/19/2008 . Edited 6/19/2008 #1,254
Fractured Illusion

Okay, here is the collective post. How about it? I wanna play a bit with the headlines after our newfound knowledge regarding the codes, though.

---

The Collected List of Authors and Genres in the Story Review Games

---

Here is a resume of what players have been active in the different review games concerning stories, and what kind of genres their stories have been. This is merely fun trivia that follows a certain formula as seen below.

---

» Formula:

Name (nicknames) - Genres the author most often asked for - Other genres they write in

---

» Stories Easy Fix, page 19-22

AlexSanguine (Sanguine) - Fantasy, Horror

Sexy vampirechick - Romance - General, Mystery, Humor, Thriller

Dot Cubed - Romance

SympleSymon (Cy, Cyclops) - Young Adult - Thriller, Manga, Humor

Katenheimer - no preference - Romance, Humor, Essay

Distilledfx - Horror - Fantasy

Jesusfreak43091 - no preference - Young Adult, Humor, Mythology, Kids, Romance, Fantasy, General, Spiritual

artificial destiny - Romance

Hammer83 - Action

dragonflydreamer (Sparkles) - Fantasy

Chewyy the Moofin - Romance

Asherah Seirei - Fantasy - Manga

N.J Robinson (Frogger) - General

Anastasia Ambrose - General

alittlebitconfused (Beta) - Romance

Erocdrah - Sci-Fi - General

Teffie (Tefflon) - Fantasy

Josh Howatt - General

Colorize - Romance

A-Q-K - Supernatural, Thriller - School, Sci-Fi, Mystery, Play, Horror

groovi-gal-numba1 - Young Adult

Harmonic Discord - Fantasy - Mythology, Sci-Fi

Silver Dollar - Romance - Humor

dreamer999 - Supernatural - General, Horror *native language Spanish

Limited Edition - Romance - Mystery, Young Adult, General, Biography, Fantasy, Horror *seems to write in Swedish as well (though I'm not sure)

Mahone-chic-89 - Romance, Action - Biography

Stargirl Lilac - Romance - Humor

Lachrymosa - Romance - Fantasy, Horror, Supernatural, Sci-Fi, Action

Equilibrium - Fantasy

EliXir15 - Fantasy

Lady Blood - Young Adult - Thriller

soojinyeh - Sci-Fi - Humor, General

Keshuoo - Romance

asylum writer (Aussie?) - Humor - Action

Dexterity (Dex) - Fantasy - General, Romance

Aasia - Fantasy

eamane tinuviel - no preference - Humor, Supernatural, Mythology

Drallimer - Romance - Young Adult

Sally Can Wait - Romance

Trmpetplaya1 - Romance - General, Fantasy

AtlantisGirl12 - General - Fable, Historical, Humor

Amertie - General

---

» Stories Depth page 11-14

- Deimus Maxiran - Sci-fi - Mystery, Fantasy

- Evera19 - Horror

- Justin A Caynon - General, Supernatural - Action, Romance

- Ogden-of-the-Moon-Clan - Romance, Supernatural

- Esther Jade (Heda) - Fantasy - General

- Sark - General, Action

- Jesse the Storyteller (Ace) - Fantasy, Horror, Mythology - Young Adult, Spiritual, Romance, Essay, Humor, Supernatural, General, Sci-fi, Kids

- Dowie - Fable - Thriller, Sci-fi

- KnittingKneedle (Ting Tong) - Young Adult, Romance

- starleaf (leafy) - Romance - Horror, Fantasy

- peaceinafrica - Fantasy - Humor

- N.J Robinson - General

- Imalefty (Lefty) - Young Adult - General, Fantasy, Romance, Humor

- B.J. Winters (B.J.) - Mystery - Thriller

- sugaplumprincess (Dr Slump) - Fantasy - Essay

- Harmonic Discord (Discy) - Fantasy - Mythology, Sci-fi

- poorkeitaro - Fantasy

- Asherah Seirei - Fantasy, Manga

- Equilibrium - Fantasy

- OceanLeviathan - Sci-fi - Fantasy

- Audy - Romance - Essay

- Arianna Sterling (Era) - Fantasy, Horror - Romance, Supernatural

- Kyllorac (Kylie) - General, Horror, Historical - Mythology, Humor

- artificial destiny (Art) - Romance

- Dexterity (Dex) - Fantasy - Romance, General

- Sercus Kaynine (Sir) - Fantasy, Historical, General

- Alexandra Jacobson - General - Young Adult

- Eyelyo - Action

- Mercyette (Mercy) - Romance, Spiritual - Fantasy

- xXRecontre-DestineeXx - Romance, General - Essay, Action

- Drallimer - Romance, Young Adult

- Distilledfx (Ant) - Horror - Fantasy

- soojinyeh - Sci-fi - Essay, Humor, General

- Kinderwhore - General, Romance

- Narc - Fantasy - Essay, Supernatural

- Josh Howatt - General

- Lorki - Fantasy - Essay

- Lew Sylva - Historical - General

- exit signs - General - Young Adult

- Anastasia Ambrose - General

- Jesusfreak43091 (Susie) - Horror, Young Adult - Humor, Kids

- Tsubasa Rose - General

- Colorize - Romance

- Erocdrah - Sci-fi - General

- Limited Edition - Romance - Mystery, Young Adult, General, Biography, Essay

- groovi-gal-numba1 - Young Adult

- AlexSanguine (Sanguine) - Fantasy, Horror

- Offering the fire - General

- Sally Can Wait - Romance

- Brian77 - Fantasy

- MaDMaS22 - Sci-fi - Fantasy, Essay

---

» Multi-Chap Depth, page 1-2:

Esther Jade (Heda) - Fantasy- General

Imalefty (Lefty) - Fantasy, Young Adult- General, Romance

Kaiyako Kagami - Manga

l. fayette - Fantasy- Historical

Arianna Sterling (Era) - Fantasy- Horror, Romance, Supernatural

Kyllorac (Kylie) - General- Mythology, Supernatural, Horror, Fantasy, Historical, Fable, Historical, Humor, Nauture

Deimus Maxiran - Sci-fi- Mystery, Fantasy

B.J. Winters (B.J.) - Mystery- Thriller

rassoodock (rassy) - Romance

KnittingKneedle (Ting Ting or TT) - Young Adult- Romance

adnapusa - Romance- Thriller, Biography, Fantasy

Narc - Fantasy- Supernatural

Harmonic Discord (Discy) - Fantasy- Mythology, Sci-fi

Robbertomo Jerome Straightpen (Geronimo) - Supernatural- General, Humor

---

» Multi-Chap Easy Fix, page 1-2:

Kelsci J. Sceasel - Young Adult

KnittingKneedle (Ting Ting or TT) - Young Adult- Romance

Kaiyako Kagami - Manga

Imalefty (Lefty) - Fantasy, Young Adult- General, Romance

l. fayette - Historical, Fantasy

Fiorenza (Fiona) - Fantasy- General

Esther Jade (Heda) - Fantasy- General

Damius - Fantasy

Kyllorac (Kylie) - General- Mythology, Supernatural, Horror, Fantasy, Historical, Fable, Historical, Humor, Nauture

loves him - Romance

Dexterity (Dex) - Fantasy- General, Romance

Oracle of Destiny - Essay, Romance- Young Adult, Humor

thefilmchick - Fantasy

KimHua - Sci-fi- Action, Spiritual, General, Supernatural

Yellers - Romance

Sexy vampirechick - Romance- General

artificial destiny (Art) - Romance

Equilibrium - Fantasy

Narc - Fantasy- Supernatural

Harmonic Discord (Discy) - Fantasy- Mythology, Sci-fi

Mercyette (Mercy) - Romance- Spiritual, Fantasy

Teffie (Teflon) - Fantasy

Jesusfreak43091 (Susie) - Romance- Kids, Fantasy, General, Spiritual

---

This post was last edited June 20th 2008, Frac's time

6/19/2008 . Edited 6/19/2008 #1,255
Fractured Illusion

@Genre-Author list

How should I present it in the first posts of the story RGs? And where? I lack inspiration...

6/19/2008 #1,256
simpleplan13

I would answer, but it seems you already made up your mind.

I asked this in OT, but how will this be maintained?

Also, do you think I list of ppl and their nicknames might also make sense? Or even just ppl who aren't in those lists already and who have nicknames?

6/19/2008 #1,257
Fractured Illusion

Also, do you think I list of ppl and their nicknames might also make sense? Or even just ppl who aren't in those lists already and who have nicknames?

As a separate list? Yeah that'd be cool! :)

I would answer, but it seems you already made up your mind.

But I don't! O_o I don't know how to incorporate it at all in the first post of the different RGs

Edit: How about I also link to the rules? :D

6/19/2008 . Edited 6/19/2008 #1,258
simpleplan13

Like I said before I would put a link in the rules. Like if you're interested in more info about the players click here. And direct them to the list.

As for the maintaince, what about Multi-chap, will you redo that after 2 pages, instead of 4?

As for separate nickname list, Yay! I will start one if you want, but I know I do not know everyone's nicknames.

6/19/2008 #1,259
simpleplan13

By also link to the rules you mean in the list, link to each RG & its rules? If so, that would work, you can just link the part where you say what RG it is for to the first page of that RG. But I would do that in addition to what I said (which is basically the same thing, just backwards...lol)

6/19/2008 #1,260
« Prev Page 1 .. 32 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 52 .. Last Next »
Forum Moderators: Fractured Illusion Dr. Self Destruct, dragonflydreamer, lookingwest, Lime-Cat, simpleplan13, Imalefty
Rules:
  • Forums are not to be used to post stories.
  • All forum posts must be suitable for teens.
  • The owner and moderators of this forum are solely responsible for the content posted within this area.
  • All forum abuse must be reported to the moderators.
Membership Length: 2+ years 1 year 6+ months 1 month 2+ weeks new member