Sixteen-year-old gothic outcast Natalie Sugarman bartered her soul for her dying mother's life eleven years ago to a boy demon. Now, she must confront the demon to win her soul back—even if that means damning five other souls to take her place.

For four years good girl Lane has regretted breaking up with Noel Falcon. She thought she was being sensible when she told him his dream of being a rock star would get him nowhere, but now that he's a rock god and she's unemployed, she realizes just how wrong she was. But when Noel comes into their hometown for a concert, Lane gets that second chance she's always dreamed of.